Chapter 10: The Wrong Bench to Blame
On Sunday morning, Mara took the old walking guide to the café before the breakfast crowd arrived. Imogen had promised her a pot of tea and the use of a table, provided Mara did not ask for toast until the delivery came.
“The bread is late,” Imogen said as she unlocked the door. “The driver’s daughter has acquired a rabbit, and apparently it got into the van.”
“Was it eating the bread?”
“I didn’t ask. I was afraid he’d tell me.”
The willow bench stood a few yards from the café window, facing the green. It was occupied by a man with a newspaper and a dog who had arranged itself across his shoes. Mara waited until they had gone, then opened the guide on the seat.
The small drawing showed the bench nearer the river, beside the path that curved away from the café. A willow tree still grew there, its branches hanging over the bank. At the bench’s present position, a young linden offered very little shade and had been tied to a stake.
Mara walked between the two places, counting her steps. From the old position, someone could watch the river; from the new one, they could see the café door and most of the green. The guide did not give a date for either the drawing or the bench’s installation.
She made a note in her fresh notebook: Willow bench present near café. Guide shows it by river. Move not recent, according to Imogen.
A delivery van turned into the square. Its driver emerged carrying two crates of bread and looking as though he had personally pursued the rabbit.
Mara held the café door while he went in. Behind the counter, Imogen examined a loaf.
“No teeth marks,” she said.
“The rabbit was only interested in the paperwork.”
“A discerning animal. Leave it on the desk next time there’s a council consultation.”
The driver laughed and went back for the second crate. Mara returned to the bench, where the guide’s pages had begun to lift in the breeze. She weighted them with her pencil.
June had known about the three absent entries. Had she known this bench had moved as well? Imogen had said the move was not recent, but she had given no other explanation. Mara looked again at the riverbank, then at the café door. The bench was close enough that Imogen could see it from the counter.
Inside, the first customers were choosing a table. Mara carried the guide in and set it beside the till.
“Have you got a moment?” she asked.
Imogen was slicing bread. “A small one.”
“The willow bench used to be down by the river, didn’t it?”
Imogen’s knife stopped. “The guide says so.”
“And now it’s here.” Mara touched the drawing. “Did you move it without permission?”
Imogen put the knife down.
At the nearest table, a woman unfolded a napkin with great care. Her companion looked fixedly at the menu, although it was displayed on a board behind him.
“Why would you ask me that here?” Imogen said.
Mara felt the warmth rise in her face. “I’m sorry. I only meant—”
“I know what you meant.”
“I’m trying to understand the difference between the guide and what’s there now.”
“And you’ve decided I took a bench?”
“No. I thought you might have moved it.”
“Without permission.”
The woman at the table stood. “I’ll just see if there’s a paper outside.”
“There isn’t one yet,” Imogen said, more gently. “But you’re welcome to look.”
The woman went out anyway. Mara closed the guide.
“I shouldn’t have put it like that.”
“No, you shouldn’t.” Imogen picked up the knife again, then set it down without cutting. “The old place flooded. More than once. June helped find somewhere safer.”
“Did she agree to the move?”
“She was there when we discussed it.” Imogen glanced toward the open door. “The donor’s family weren’t all consulted. I should have dealt with that better, and I don’t intend to discuss them over somebody’s breakfast.”
Mara wanted to ask who else had been involved, whether any permission had been written down, whether June had recorded the new position. Every question seemed likely to make Imogen’s hands tighten further around the edge of the counter.
“All right,” she said.
Imogen fetched the teapot she had promised and placed it on a tray. “You can still use the table.”
“Thank you.”
The woman came back without a newspaper. Mara took the tray to the far end of the café and poured tea she did not particularly want. Imogen brought out toast and asked the couple whether they needed anything else. She sounded like herself again, which somehow made Mara feel worse.
Mara opened her notebook and crossed out the words she had begun to write: possible unauthorized move. She had not seen a record either way. Imogen had given her an account of flooding and June’s involvement; Mara could write that much, with Imogen’s name beside it.
She did so.
Before leaving, she carried the tray back to the counter. “I’m sorry I asked in front of your customers.”
Imogen accepted the empty pot. “I have to get their breakfast out.”
Mara nodded and went outside. It was not forgiveness, but neither was it an invitation to stand there until Imogen found a kinder answer.
The river path was damp beneath the trees. Theo stood near the old willow, holding a narrow board against a post while he inspected it from several angles.
“Is that the revised sign?” Mara asked.
“No. This is a piece of wood I’m trying to persuade Peter not to use for the revised sign.”
“What has it done wrong?”
“It’s warped. If I paint an arrow on it, people will think the path turns uphill.”
He lowered the board. Mara could see the bend now, slight but unmistakable.
“Are you working on a Sunday?” she asked.
“I came to measure. The board came along because Peter wanted my opinion on whether it could be reused.” Theo tucked it under his arm. “He’ll have it by Monday, along with a recommendation that it become a shelf.”
Mara told him she was looking at the willow bench’s former position. She left out the conversation in the café until he asked why she was standing in front of a tree with her guide open.
“I accused Imogen of moving the bench without permission,” she said.
“Did you?”
“I asked if she had. In front of customers.”
Theo considered her. “How many?”
“Two.”
“A select audience, then.”
“She wasn’t amused.”
“I wouldn’t expect her to be.”
Mara shut the guide. “You needn’t sound quite so pleased about it.”
“I’m not pleased. I’m trying to imagine Imogen’s face and failing to produce anything reassuring.”
Despite herself, Mara smiled. “She said the old place flooded and June helped find a safer one. She also said the donor’s family weren’t all consulted.”
Theo looked toward the river. “That part sounds familiar. I remember water across this bit of path after heavy rain, though I couldn’t tell you which year the bench moved.”
He stepped off the path onto a patch of grass, then stopped before the ground sloped down to the bank. “You can still see where the mud settles.”
A dark line marked the lower trunks and the edge of the path. Small twigs lay caught in the grass above it.
“Does it reach this far often?” Mara asked.
“Not every time it rains. When the river’s high, it can sit here for a while.” He pointed to the willow’s roots, where the ground dipped. “The old bench was nearer that hollow. I remember someone putting a board down so people could get past without losing a shoe.”
“Who?”
“I don’t remember. It may have been me.” He frowned. “I wouldn’t put it in your notebook as a fact.”
“I’m learning to leave you out of my notebook.”
“An excellent policy.”
She walked to the hollow. From there she could see the appeal of the old position: the river widened beyond a bend, and the willow branches framed the water. She could also see why a person approaching after a flood might have to choose between sitting in the wet and turning back.
“Imogen didn’t say it was all right to move it just because the ground flooded,” Mara said.
“No. And I can’t tell you what permission she had.” Theo rested the board against the post. “I can tell you the wet ground was a real nuisance. Those are separate things.”
Mara looked back toward the café. The linden beside the bench was thin enough that she could see the shop window through its leaves. “I wanted the discrepancy to have an explanation.”
“It probably does.”
“I wanted one I could put in a sentence.”
“You can still put it in a sentence. It may take more than one.”
She opened her notebook. Under Imogen’s account, she added Theo’s recollection of flooding, including his uncertainty about the year and the board. He watched her write, then shifted the warped plank from one hand to the other.
“I should apologize properly,” she said.
“You did, didn’t you?”
“For asking in front of customers. I didn’t get as far as apologizing for the assumption.”
“Give her a little room to finish breakfast first.”
They walked toward the green together. Theo stopped to hold the gate for a woman pushing a pram, then waited while one wheel caught briefly on the edge of the path. The woman freed it herself and thanked him. He made a note of the uneven patch on a scrap of paper.
“For Peter?” Mara asked.
“For me. I keep catching the trolley there when I deliver signs.” He folded the paper. “Peter can have it too.”
At the café, Imogen was carrying plates to the window table. She saw Mara through the glass and gave her a brief nod before turning back to her customers. Mara raised a hand but did not go in.
The willow bench was still occupied by the man and his dog, who must have returned while they were at the river. He had moved his newspaper aside to make room for a woman with a shopping bag. They were discussing whether the sky looked like rain.
Mara checked the guide once more. The willow bench had been moved from one known place to another. The heron and station benches were absent, with accounts of recent removals that still needed checking. The orchard entry remained a purchase and a symbol on a page; she did not know whether a bench had ever stood there.
She could not use one difference to explain the others.
“I’m going to make a cleaner copy of my notes,” she said.
Theo glanced at the pages. “Will that improve the handwriting?”
“No. But it may improve the thinking.”
He picked up his board. “If it works, let me know. I have a sign to write.”
Mara watched him go, then took the longer path home behind the library. In her notebook, beside the willow entry, she left space for Imogen’s account when Imogen was ready to give it. She had made enough room for an answer. Now she needed to let someone else decide when to offer it.