Chapter 8: Familiar Paper
On my way home from the Lantern, I went back to the studio.
I told myself I was only going to collect the notebook I had left beside the computer. I had my keys out before I reached the door, though, and once inside I went straight to the cabinet where I had put the photograph.
The building was quiet. Someone had left a light on in the corridor outside the print room, but the door was locked. I could hear a radio through it, turned low enough that the voice rose and fell without becoming words.
I opened the cabinet and checked the enclosure. My initials and Friday’s date were on the label, beside the description I had written. I had put the wrong day first and corrected it to Friday. The crossed-out word was still legible.
There was a message from Nadia on my phone.
Are you coming in? I’m finishing the treatment notes.
I wrote that I was there. A few minutes later she appeared in the doorway with her coat over one arm.
“I thought you were going home.”
“I was. I wanted to look at the photographs we took.”
She set her coat down. “Any word?”
I told her about Lena’s leave, the scanner and Tom’s account of Wednesday’s call. I repeated his words carefully: Lena had sounded frightened, but had not said Simon threatened her.
“And Beth?” Nadia asked.
“She spoke to Lena last week. She said she’ll tell the police herself.”
Nadia waited. I had not told her about asking Beth to discuss the accident. I did not want another account of that conversation in the room, especially one in which Nadia might ask why I had made the call the way I did.
“I’d like to look at the edge again,” I said.
She glanced at the cabinet. “What are you hoping to see?”
“I’m not sure. A better view of the pale layer, perhaps.”
“We can look.”
We washed our hands and cleared the bench. I took the mount out in its enclosure and opened it on the support. The right-hand corner of the caption was raised by the smallest amount; the narrow gap tapered left along its lower edge. I still could not tell whether the movement had happened before I removed the mount from the sleeve.
Nadia adjusted the lamp while I positioned the magnifier. The shallow light made the edge cast a narrow shadow. I could see the irregular pale line underneath, but no further than before.
“Try moving it a little farther back,” Nadia said.
I moved the lamp. The line became less distinct, then returned as I angled the light again. There was a faint pattern on the exposed surface, a slight unevenness that might have been part of the paper or the way the light caught damage at the edge.
I knew that texture.
Dad had kept a packet of cream paper in the bottom drawer of his desk. It was thicker than the sheets in the printer and had a soft, uneven surface. He used it for labels and cards. We were allowed to use the scraps, provided we put the packet back and swept the cuttings into the bin.
“Dad had paper like that,” I said.
Nadia leaned down to look. “Like which part?”
“The exposed edge. There was a packet in his desk drawer.”
She studied it for another moment. “It’s a very small area.”
“I know.”
“And plenty of paper has that kind of surface.”
“I know that too.” I moved aside to let her look through the magnifier. “I wasn’t saying it was from the packet.”
She took her time. “I can see why it reminded you. That’s as far as I’d go.”
I looked at the caption while she spoke. The pale edge disappeared beneath the visible strip. It might have been paper; it might have been part of the damaged mounting layer. Even if it was paper from Dad’s drawer, that would only put the material in the house. I could hear myself making those distinctions, and underneath them I could feel the pleasure of recognition.
“Lena and I used to make things at his desk,” I said. “Cards, mostly. She’d cut the paper and I’d rule lines for her.”
“What kind of lines?”
“To keep the writing straight.”
Nadia looked up. “Did you ever work on the album?”
“I don’t remember doing anything to it.” I saw her expression and added, “That isn’t the same as saying I didn’t.”
She nodded. “Do you remember handling this photograph?”
“No. I remember the paper. And the paste.”
There had been a small white dish with a chip in its foot. Lena had mixed the paste in it with a teaspoon, pressing out the lumps against the side. I had complained about the smell, and she had told me not to put my face so close. I remembered the spoon tapping the dish when she handed it to me.
“How old were you?” Nadia asked.
“A teenager, I think. We did things like that more than once.”
“Then it may have nothing to do with this.”
“It may not.”
I could remember sitting with Lena at the desk, the window open behind us. There had been a strip of paper between us, and Lena had asked me to hold it flat. I had been annoyed because she kept moving the ruler after I had lined it up. It was the sort of job she gave me when she wanted a neat result and did not want to do it herself.
I had not thought about the afternoon for years. Now I could almost feel the damp paper against my fingertip. I could not place the strip among the cards and labels we had made, and I did not try to give it a purpose.
Nadia had gone back to her own bench to fetch a pencil. When she returned, she pointed beside the raised corner.
“The surface there is different from the area around it, as we noted yesterday. But I can’t say what caused that. If you want another photograph, use the same scale and record the light position.”
I did. We did not touch the corner or try to see farther beneath it. On the computer screen the enlarged image made the pale edge look broad enough to identify. At the bench it was still a sliver.
I added a note that the texture reminded me of paper kept at Daniel’s house, followed by Nadia’s caution about the limited area and the commonness of similar surfaces. I left the observation separate from the handling record.
“Are you going back there?” Nadia asked.
“To the house?”
“You’re thinking about it.”
“There might still be some of the paper.”
“Then you can look at it. Just be careful what you call a match.”
I closed the file. “I thought you were going home.”
“I am. You said that half an hour ago.”
She helped me return the mount to its enclosure. After she left, I checked the label and put it back in the cabinet. I took my notebook with me.
Daniel’s house was a short drive from the studio. By the time I arrived, the light had begun to fade behind the houses opposite. I let myself in with my key and locked the door behind me.
The study still smelled faintly of furniture polish. On my previous visit I had left the albums stacked at one end of the desk, apart from the one I had taken to the studio. A sheet of inventory paper lay beside them under a paperweight. I had meant to put it in the folder.
I did that first. Then I opened the bottom drawer.
A ball of string had worked loose from its wrapper. There were two blunt pencils, a dried marker and a box of paper clips with one corner split. I lifted each item out and put it on the desk. At the back lay a flattened tube of adhesive, stiff when I picked it up. The packet of cream paper was gone.
I checked the other drawers. Dad had kept bills in one and instruction booklets in another, each group held with an elastic band. Several bands had perished, leaving dark fragments on the paper beneath. I found an old birthday card Lena had sent him and a small ruler with her name scratched into the back. No paper packet.
I sat down in his chair. From there I could see the rectangle of lighter wood where the desk calendar had stood. Dad had taken it away each January and replaced it with a new one, even after he began using the calendar on his phone. He liked being able to see the month without touching anything.
I had expected the paper to be in its usual place. The disappointment felt out of proportion. The drawer had been sorted during the clearance, and a packet of scraps was exactly the sort of thing someone might have thrown away. I had filled bags myself, making quick decisions about envelopes and dried pens while trying not to think about the rooms becoming empty.
I opened the inventory folder again. There was an entry for stationery from the study, with a note that usable supplies had been put in a box with loose papers for later sorting. The box was in the spare bedroom.
It was under a chair, its flaps folded over one another. I carried it to the bed and opened it. On top were a school notebook and a bundle of old utility bills. Beneath them I found a brown paper packet folded around several offcuts.
The paper inside ranged from long strips to pieces too small for more than a word or two. Some had pencil marks where shapes had been measured and cut away. One had a corner missing in a curve. I turned it over: blank.
The surface looked much as I remembered. I held a piece near the window, then put it down again. The room was too dim for a useful comparison, and I did not have the mount with me. Even under good light, a resemblance would not show that the exposed edge came from this packet.
Dad had kept the paper. Lena and I had used his desk. I wanted those facts to lead directly to him making the caption, and they did not.
My phone vibrated in my coat pocket. I took it out so quickly that I dropped the packet onto the bed.
A message from Tom: I’ve told the police about Wednesday’s call. Finn’s home. No word from Lena.
I read it twice. Then I wrote, Thank you for letting me know. I’m at Dad’s house. I haven’t heard from her either.
He did not reply immediately. I put the phone beside the box and gathered the scraps back into their packet.
In my notebook I wrote where I had found them and what I could see: cream paper offcuts in a folded brown wrapper, stored among papers from the study. Then I added that I had not compared them directly with the mount and could not identify the exposed edge from sight.
I stopped before closing the notebook. I had written about the paste in my studio note, but only as a memory of materials in the house. I added that Lena and I had mixed it together when we were younger. The sentence looked insignificant beneath the longer description of the packet. I left it there.
As I returned the box beneath the chair, my phone lit up again. This time it was only the screen waking when I brushed it with my sleeve.
I stood for a moment with the packet still in my hand. Lena had known where Dad kept the paper. So had I. I put it back in the box and closed the flaps, leaving the notebook on top where I had found it.