Chapter 23 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 20: The Tree for Nell

I went to the orchard on Sunday morning with a paper bag of scones and a question for Marjorie.

The scones were Marnie’s doing. She had appeared at my door with six, announced that she had made twice as many as she needed, and refused to take any back.

“You could freeze them,” I said.

“I could. Or you could stop looking at that notebook and take a walk.”

I had closed Peg’s notebook, but apparently not quickly enough.

The grass beyond the gap in the hedge was damp around my shoes. Most of the blossom had fallen, leaving small green apples among the leaves. At the far end of the orchard I saw Marjorie kneeling beside Nell’s tree, a garden fork on the ground next to her.

She heard me before I reached her and turned, one hand pressed to her knee.

“Cora. I thought it might be Rufus.”

“Am I in his way?”

“No. I asked him last week whether he minded my tending this bit. He said he had enough weeds of his own.” She looked at the bag. “Have you brought him breakfast?”

“Scones. I was hoping to find someone to share them with.”

“That depends. Did you make them?”

“Marnie did.”

“Oh, good.” She held out her hand, and I helped her up. “I do like your honey cake, dear, but your scones have a determined crust.”

“They keep for weeks.”

“I imagine archaeologists will find them.”

She brushed soil from her skirt. There was a shallow ring of freshly turned earth around the tree, and a small watering can stood in the shade of the hedge. Marjorie had wedged a folded newspaper beneath its handle to keep the breeze from carrying it away.

“Ivy’s making a display for the shop,” I said. “About the orchard. She asked whether she could mention Nell’s tree.”

Marjorie bent to pick up the fork. “What would she say?”

“That it was planted in Nell’s memory. Nothing more unless you wanted it there.”

For a moment she examined the fork’s muddy prongs. “Yes. She may say that.”

“Would you like to see what she writes?”

“I would, thank you. Ivy has a good eye. She made the sign for the fair stall, didn’t she?”

“She did. She’ll be pleased you noticed.”

“She moved it three times before she was satisfied. I had plenty of opportunity.”

We sat on the low bank beyond the tree. Marjorie accepted a scone and broke it neatly in two; I managed to scatter mine over my lap. A blackbird landed near the watering can and began inspecting the disturbed earth.

“I planted it the spring after Nell died,” she said. “The first one didn’t take. That was my fault. I put it too close to the hedge, and the roots had a fight I should have known they’d lose.”

“So this is the second?”

“Yes. Rufus’s father helped me choose it. He brought the stake and stayed to put it in straight.” She smiled. “He checked it twice before he left. I think he suspected I might improve upon his work.”

“Would you have?”

“Certainly.”

The trunk was slender beside the older trees, but its branches spread wide enough to cast a little shade. Marjorie watched the blackbird tug a worm from the soil and carry it away.

“People sometimes assume she’s buried here,” she said. “She isn’t. I planted it because she liked coming to the orchard.”

“I remember seeing her at the fair. She had a yellow ribbon in her hair.”

Marjorie turned towards me. “Did she?”

“I think so. Bram showed me a photograph, and I may be borrowing it from that.”

“She wore one often enough. She was forever losing ribbons and accusing me of taking them.” Marjorie picked a currant from her scone. “Sometimes I had.”

I laughed, and she did too. Then she folded the remaining half into her handkerchief.

“Dawn has spoken to you,” she said.

I looked at her. “Yes.”

“About the night Nell died?”

“She told me what she heard at the house. She wasn’t at the cottage.”

“No.” Marjorie smoothed the handkerchief over her knee. “She wasn’t.”

“She’s contacted the police.”

“I thought she might.” Her voice was steady, but she had caught the edge of the cloth between two fingers and was twisting it. “Gil would have hated that.”

“Dawn has the right to tell them what she heard.”

“I didn’t say she hadn’t.”

The blackbird returned, saw us move and flew up into the branches. I wanted to ask Marjorie what had happened at the cottage, and whether the confidence Peg had kept belonged to that night. I could hear Okonkwo telling me I did not need to conduct an interview.

“I’m sorry,” I said. “I sounded as though I thought you were trying to stop her.”

“I’ve had a good deal of practice at stopping people.” Marjorie released the handkerchief. “That’s not quite what I meant to say.”

She leaned forward to retrieve the garden fork, though it was already within reach, and laid it across her lap.

“Peg knew some things,” she said. “I told her myself, years afterwards. She never pressed me to tell her more than I could bear.”

“She wrote that you’d asked her to keep a confidence.”

Marjorie’s eyes came to mine. “Did she write what it was?”

“No.”

“Thank goodness for that.” She gave a small, tired smile. “I suppose I ought to be cross with her for writing anything at all.”

“She wrote it as a reminder to let you decide what to do.”

“That sounds like Peg.” Marjorie looked down at the fork. “Does truth always have to be told to everyone, Cora?”

The question seemed too large for the patch of grass between us.

“I don’t know,” I said. “I don’t think everyone is entitled to every part of someone else’s life.”

“And the police?”

“I’ve told them what I know. They’re trying to find out what happened to Gil.”

Marjorie drew one line in the earth with a prong of the fork. “Of course they are.”

I waited, but she did not go on. When I offered her another scone, she shook her head and stood, more slowly than she had before.

“I should finish here. The weeds won’t pull themselves up, however long I sit looking at them.”

I gathered the bag and helped her settle the watering can beside the tree. She thanked me and asked me to tell Ivy she could come and see it whenever she liked.

At the gap in the hedge I looked back. Marjorie was kneeling again, loosening the soil around a stubborn root. She did not look up.


Tom came to the shop that afternoon to return a screwdriver he had borrowed from the yard. He placed it on the counter beside the till, where I was pretending to sort receipts.

“You’ve brought it back,” I said. “I was beginning to think it had joined your family.”

“It had a perfectly comfortable home in my coat pocket.”

“Was it getting on with the other screwdrivers?”

“They were wary at first.”

I made tea, and we sat at the small table by the window. Ivy’s draft display was propped against the wall behind him, its painted branch curling over the blank space she had left for information about the orchard.

I told him about finding Marjorie at Nell’s tree and about her question. I left out the moment when she had twisted her handkerchief; it felt too easily turned into evidence.

“She knows you’ve heard something,” Tom said.

“Yes. She asked whether I thought everyone had to be told the truth.”

“And you said?”

“That I didn’t know.”

“That seems fair.”

“I wish I’d had something better to give her.”

He glanced at the receipts. “Is that what you’ve been trying to work out?”

“Among other things.” I pushed them aside. “Dawn saw her with Gil’s jacket and case before the fair, or at least knew she had them for a short time. She didn’t see what Marjorie did.”

“Other people had opportunities too.”

“Yes. Okonkwo said there was an inconsistency in the case and its contents. She didn’t tell me exactly what it was, or who caused it.” I wrapped my hands around the cup. “And Gil’s ledger suggests some sort of arrangement with Marjorie. We don’t know what it means.”

Tom nodded. “None of that tells us what happened by itself.”

“I keep wanting it to.”

I thought instead of the doorway at Dawn’s house. Marjorie had come out wearing her cardigan; Gil had appeared afterwards with his jacket over his arm.

“Dawn left the jacket with Marjorie,” I said. “But Gil had it when I arrived.”

Tom put down his cup. “Someone handed it back.”

“And I don’t know who saw that happen. I’ve been asking about the time Marjorie was alone, but there may have been someone there between Dawn’s return and mine.”

“Could Dawn remember?”

“I can ask her. She can decide whether to tell the police.”

I wrote jacket handover on the back of a receipt before I could lose the thought.

Outside, a couple stopped at Ivy’s display in the window. The woman pointed at the painted bee, and the man leaned closer to read the heading. I wondered what they would make of the empty space beneath it.

“I thought about going back to Marjorie,” I said. “Asking her outright.”

“What would you ask?”

“Whether she did something to Gil’s case.”

Tom looked at me. “Do you want an answer, or do you want her to tell you she didn’t?”

I could have given him a quick answer. He waited while I found a less comfortable one.

“Both, probably. Which is a poor reason to put the question to her.”

“You can still tell Okonkwo about this morning.”

“I know.” I looked towards the telephone behind the counter. “Marjorie trusted me enough to speak about Peg.”

“She may have. You can tell the detective what she actually said.”

I got up before I could begin arranging the conversation into something tidier. Okonkwo was unavailable, so I left a message with her colleague: where I had met Marjorie, what she had said about Peg and Dawn, and the question she had asked me. I included my answer.

When I put down the receiver, Tom was gathering the receipts into a pile.

“You don’t have to do that,” I said.

“I know. I’m trying to find out whether the shop can afford another packet of biscuits.”

“It depends. Are you planning to eat them?”

“Only if invited.”

I fetched the tin. Ivy’s apples watched us from the wall while I chose two biscuits and left the rest for her.