Chapter 6 of 35

AI-generated book by Nora WestleyBook rights and permissions

Chapter 3: Three Empty Marks

Earlier that afternoon, after leaving June at the library and before going to the evening meeting, Mara returned to the river with the copied list in her pocket.

The sun had shifted since morning, leaving the bend in the path half in shade. The patch where the heron bench had stood looked smaller than she remembered. A cyclist passed, then a woman with a terrier that stopped to investigate Mara’s shoelace.

“I’m afraid I haven’t brought anything interesting,” Mara told it.

The terrier continued its inspection. Its owner apologized and coaxed it onward.

Mara crouched beside the disturbed ground. At one end, a flat metal plate lay close to the earth, with holes in it and a shallow coating of dirt. It seemed a plain, practical thing to have drawn her all the way back from the library, but June had asked for what she could see.

She took out her notebook and sketched the plate, adding the holes and the rough line of the surrounding ground. Then she copied the inventory number from June’s list beside the drawing.

There was no label on the plate. The number came from an old maintenance note, June had said, and she did not know whether anyone had checked it against the bench. Mara drew a line between the number and the words June’s note, just in case she looked at the page later and forgot.

She leaned back on her heels. The two shallow impressions were still visible where she had seen them that morning, but the ground offered no neat date for the bench’s departure. Grass had begun to bend over one edge. That might have taken days or weeks, depending on the weather and how often people walked there.

A shadow fell across her notebook.

“Found anything?” asked the man in the yellow waterproof jacket.

He was without the dog this time and carrying a loaf of bread under one arm.

“Only the place where it used to be.”

“That’s what I found too.” He considered the plate. “My wife says there was a wobble in the seat. I don’t remember one myself, but she sat on it more often.”

“Did she happen to see anyone take it away?”

“I don’t think so. We were away for a few days, and when we came back, there it wasn’t.” He frowned. “Or perhaps it was the week before we went. I’d better ask her before I make a liar of us both.”

“I’d be grateful if you did.”

He gave her his name—Martin Daley—and accepted one of her spare slips of paper with the library’s number written on it.

“Mrs. Daley likes a useful errand,” he said. “Especially if it ends at the library. She can return her books and tell them the large-print shelf needs moving down one.”

“Does it?”

“She says the top shelf defeats the purpose.”

After he had gone, Mara added the observation to her page. She had not set out to redesign the library, but the shelf seemed worth mentioning to someone who could.

She stood and looked along the path. From the empty site, the nearest visible seat was back on the green. A person could see it clearly, which was different from being able to reach it comfortably. She marked the distance approximately on her working map and wrote check with walkers, resisting the urge to turn her own estimate into a fact.

On her way across the green, Mara stopped at the café to leave June’s packet for Imogen. The counter was busy, and Imogen was carrying two cups to a table by the window. Mara set the packet beside the till and went on her way.


The former station garden lay west of the green, past the library and a row of shops whose upper windows still carried the names of businesses long gone. The old station building stood beyond the garden wall, its windows reflecting the afternoon sky. Mara remembered catching a train there as a child, though she could not remember where she had gone. Her mother had packed sandwiches with too much mustard; that detail had survived perfectly.

The garden gate opened with a scrape. Within three steps, a piece of gravel slid beneath Mara’s shoe and sent her hand toward the wall. She steadied herself, looked around to see whether anyone had witnessed it, and found an elderly man on the opposite path watching with interest.

“Gate’s worse when it rains,” he said.

“I’ll be sure to fall on a dry day.”

“That’s sensible.” He went back to inspecting a rosebush.

The guide placed the station bench near the far wall, facing a bed of late flowers. Mara followed the path to the spot. Two empty supports stood there, spaced for a seat, with gaps in the gravel around them. The lighter patches looked fresh beside the surrounding stones, but she could not say how long they had been exposed. Someone might have disturbed the ground while gardening, or rain might have washed it clean.

She made another sketch. The supports were different from the flat plate at the river, though she did not know enough about bench fittings to say what that meant. She wrote down the difference without trying to explain it.

The man by the roses wandered over.

“Looking for Nell Harwood’s bench? It was for her brother.”

“I’m checking the station-garden bench for the library,” Mara said. “I didn’t know who it was connected with.”

“That’s the one.” He put his hands in his pockets. “I used to see her here with a flask. Never offered me any.”

“Perhaps she didn’t bring enough.”

“She brought a very large flask.”

Mara smiled. “Do you know when the bench was taken away?”

He tipped his head. “It was here when the roses were pruned.”

“When was that?”

“I didn’t do them this year. My daughter did.” He studied the bushes as if they might supply a calendar. “I’ll ask her.”

Mara gave him another slip with the library’s number. He read it, folded it carefully, and introduced himself as Mr. Pritchard.

“Nell will have something to say about the bench,” he added.

“I expect someone will raise it at the meeting tonight.”

“Then you’ll hear Nell.”

He returned to his roses. Mara stood at the empty supports, imagining a person seated there with a flask and a view of the flowers. June’s list mentioned a transfer, but June had not known what the notation meant. The empty supports could not tell Mara whether it referred to this site, or when any transfer had happened.

It was tempting to fill the space in, especially when the guide showed a bench so confidently. Instead she drew an open circle beside the station-garden entry.

As she closed her notebook, she noticed a small paper cup caught beneath the wall. She picked it up and carried it to the bin by the gate. Mr. Pritchard watched her go.

“Now you’ve done it,” he called.

“Done what?”

“The cup was holding that bit of gravel in place.”

She looked back at the gate. “I’ll take a different route out.”

“There isn’t one.”

“That does explain the problem.”


The orchard path ran south from the green, between low hedges and a stretch of old trees whose fruit was beginning to color. Mara found the place where the guide showed a bench: a widening beside the path, with a view toward the footbridge. No seat stood there.

The ground was firm and uneven under the grass. She could see nothing that told her whether a bench had once occupied it. June had found a purchase entry, but nothing establishing when the bench had been put here. Her question mark seemed more useful than any answer Mara could supply.

A man was working nearby with a pair of shears, trimming a branch that leaned over the path. He set the shears down when he saw her.

“Am I in your way?” he asked.

“Not at all. I’m checking the place where the guide shows a bench.”

He looked at the widening. “Is that still in the guide?”

“It is.”

“Then the guide’s been more optimistic than the rest of us.” He wiped his hands on his trousers. “Gus Fenner. I used to work on the grounds here.”

“Mara Ellis. I’m making an updated map for the library.”

“Ellis.” He looked at her more closely. “You’re Joan’s daughter. She made a very determined complaint when we cut back the hedge outside her house.”

“She liked the hedge.”

“She liked the sparrows in it. We’d been a bit enthusiastic.” Gus gave the branch a rueful glance. “I learned to look before I started after that.”

Mara showed him the guide. “Do you remember a bench being here?”

“I remember talk of one. There was a plan for a resting place along this path.” He pointed toward the open patch. “Might have been just here.”

“Was it ever installed?”

Gus did not answer at once. He walked to the edge of the widening and looked down, then across toward the footbridge.

“I can picture a bench,” he said finally. “But I can picture the drawing on the plan as well. I wouldn’t like to swear which one I’m remembering.”

“That’s helpful.”

He raised his eyebrows. “Is it? I thought I’d managed to tell you almost nothing.”

“You’ve told me there was a plan, and that your memory doesn’t settle the rest.”

“Well, when you put it like that, I sound quite careful.”

“Very careful.”

“Don’t tell anyone. They’ll expect it every time.”

Mara noted his words, including the uncertainty. “Would Evan Rook know?”

“He keeps the maintenance records now. If there was a job sheet for it, he might find one.” Gus picked up the shears. “He’s good at keeping things going, Evan. Fixed the library gate last winter when the catch wouldn’t hold.”

“I’ll ask him.”

“You’ll probably see him at the meeting. Everyone else seems to be going, including people who haven’t walked the river path since the last meeting about it.”

“Are you going?”

“I am. Someone has to explain that trees don’t move themselves when a path gets wider.”

He clipped the offending branch and laid it neatly on the grass. Mara thanked him and continued a little way toward the footbridge. From there she could see why the wider place might have seemed suitable for a seat: the path rose gently behind her, and the bridge was still some distance ahead. She could also see why neither the guide’s symbol nor Gus’s memory of a plan established that a seat had ever stood there.

She returned to the widening and opened her map against the trunk of an apple tree. The paper curled at one corner. She held it flat and drew the third open circle.

Heron. Station garden. Orchard.

Three marks, alike in shape and different in almost every other respect. She wrote site empty beside the first two and guide shows bench; installation unconfirmed beside the third. Beneath them she added Gus’s name and a reminder to ask Evan about records.

By the time she reached the green again, the light had begun to soften. People were crossing toward the bandstand with folded leaflets and the purposeful expressions of those who intended to be heard. Mara paused to shake gravel from one shoe. A surprising quantity came out.

Imogen, passing with a covered plate, looked down at it.

“You’ve brought half the station garden.”

“I left Mr. Pritchard to guard the rest.”

“Then it’s in safe hands. Come along. Peter’s already rearranged the chairs twice, which means the meeting must be starting.”

The bell rang from the bandstand as Mara tucked the map and her notes into her bag. She followed Imogen across the green toward the gathering.