Chapter 20: Nell Remembers Again
On Wednesday morning, Nell Harwood opened her kitchen door before Mara had knocked a second time.
“I saw you coming through the window,” she said. “I’ve made tea, and I’d like you to sit down before I change my mind.”
Mara followed her in. The table was set for two, with a plate of biscuits between the cups and a small paper bag beside Nell’s place. Nell did not offer the bag.
“I’ve been thinking about what I told you,” she said. “About the night June died.”
Mara sat. Nell poured the tea with great care, leaving a pale circle at the top of each cup.
“You said you weren’t sure whether you’d seen or heard Evan’s keys,” Mara said.
“I wasn’t. That was true.” Nell pressed her lips together. “It wasn’t the whole difficulty.”
She picked up the paper bag and tipped its contents onto the table: a folded shop receipt and a length of green ribbon.
“I went to deliver a birthday surprise that evening. I didn’t want the person receiving it to know, so when people began asking where I’d been, I made the errand sound quicker than it was.”
“Has the birthday happened?”
“Yes. And she liked the surprise very much, which makes the rest of this particularly annoying.”
Mara waited while Nell straightened the ribbon.
“I bought a tin of lavender biscuits for my cousin Mavis,” Nell said. “She’d mentioned them once, in April, and I’d managed to keep them hidden until September. I wanted to leave them at her house without her seeing me.”
“That sounds difficult.”
“It was. Her neighbor caught me at the gate and insisted I come in while she found some ribbon. I’d forgotten mine.”
Nell touched the green strip. “She had a whole drawer of it. Choosing took time. She cut a length for the tin, and there was a piece left over. I put it in my handbag, intending to give it back to her.”
Mara looked at the receipt. “Is that for the biscuits?”
“For replacement ribbon. I bought it at the little shop near Mavis’s the following morning. I took the unused piece with me to match the color, then forgot to give it back. Mrs. Kemp would have refused money, but she does like a properly stocked drawer.”
She unfolded the receipt. Mara could see a date, though it was the morning after June’s death, not the evening itself.
“That can show when you bought it,” Mara said. “It can’t tell us how long you were there.”
“I know. Mrs. Kemp can tell them I was there, though. She’s the neighbor. I spoke to her yesterday, and she remembers because she burned her toast while we were choosing.”
Nell pushed the receipt aside and clasped her hands.
“I passed the bandstand on my way to Mavis’s. Its door was closed. I didn’t touch it, and I didn’t see anyone shut it. I thought it had been locked because that was what usually happened after a meeting. Before I reached the door, I heard raised voices from that direction. I couldn’t make out the words or say whose they were.”
“And Evan?”
“Later. After I’d left the biscuits and walked back toward the green.” Nell took a breath. “He was at the bandstand door. I saw him put a key in and turn it.”
Mara kept her pencil in her notebook. “You’re sure you remember the key turning?”
“I’ve asked myself that rather a lot.” Nell looked toward the window. “The loose piece of ribbon caught on the clasp of my handbag when I went to take out my handkerchief. I stopped to free it, and that was when I saw him at the door. I heard the lock. He turned, and I said good evening.”
“Did he answer?”
“He waved. I don’t remember him saying anything.” Nell’s voice grew firmer. “The first time I passed, the door was already shut. The second time, I saw him turn the key. I put the two moments together afterward, as though I’d seen the lock on my first pass.”
Mara opened her notebook. “May I write that down?”
“Please. I’m tired of carrying it around in the wrong order.”
Mara noted the two passes, the indistinct voices and the key. Nell asked her to add that she had not tried the door on either pass.
“When you mentioned the keys before, you said you might have been remembering his usual habit,” Mara said.
“I was afraid I might be. Then Mavis thanked me again for the biscuits, and I remembered Mrs. Kemp’s ribbon and where it caught. I called her to ask about that evening. She remembered me and the toast. She couldn’t tell me what I saw at the bandstand.”
Mara looked at her notes. “That night, Imogen asked whether you’d spoken to Evan. You said no.”
Nell’s hand stopped on the ribbon. “I did. I was thinking of a conversation, and I remembered being in a hurry. But I did call good evening to him. I should have said so when I remembered.”
“Will you tell Leila that as well?”
“Yes. She ought to know I gave a different answer before.”
“Have you spoken to her since we talked in your garden?”
“No. I meant to call, and then I kept wondering whether I was making it worse.” Nell looked down at the biscuit plate. “I should have called.”
Mara put down her pencil. “Would you like me to come with you?”
Nell considered. “Yes. But I’ll tell her myself.”
At the police station, the receptionist found them two chairs. Nell sat with her handbag on her lap and the receipt inside it.
“I feel as though I’m waiting outside the headmistress’s office,” she whispered.
“Did you often do that?”
“Only when I worked at the school. The children were much calmer about it.”
Leila came out to meet them. Mara explained that Nell wished to correct her account and had asked for company. Leila led them into an interview room and invited Nell to begin.
Nell gave Leila the sequence herself, including the raised voices she could not identify, her visit to Mrs. Kemp and the ribbon caught on her handbag. When she reached the key, she paused.
“I saw Evan turn it,” she said. “I heard it as well. I did not see him close the door, and I didn’t test whether it was locked before then.”
Leila asked questions about where Nell had stood and what she could see. Nell answered some immediately; for others she closed her eyes, then admitted she could not be certain.
“There’s something else I need to correct,” she said. “That night, Imogen