Chapter 5: The Loose Edge
Nadia was at the sink when I arrived, rinsing a brush under a thin stream of water. She looked up as I put the carrier on the table by my bench.
“You found it?”
“In an album at Dad’s house.”
She dried the brush handle. “And Lena?”
“No.”
I took the album from the carrier. The bakery bag had survived the journey on the passenger seat. I put it in the kitchen area, away from the work surfaces, and found two pastries inside: an almond croissant and something filled with cheese. Simon had chosen the croissant for me. He had remembered correctly.
Nadia came over, wiping her hands on a towel. “Tom called?”
“Not since this morning. He told the police about some maps and keys Lena was packing on Tuesday.”
“Did they tell him anything?”
“Only to get in touch if he remembered more.”
She looked at the album but did not open it. “Have you eaten?”
I thought of Tom’s toast and the bread I had left on his counter. “I will.”
“Mara.”
“I’ll eat the croissant now.”
She waited while I fetched it. I stood at the sink, breaking it into pieces over a plate. The flakes clung to my fingers. Nadia returned to her bench, where a torn document lay beneath a sheet of transparent material. She had left a pencil across her notebook to mark the page.
When I had finished, I washed my hands, dried them thoroughly and cleared a space at my bench. I brought out the camera stand, a scale and a sheet of clean paper. The light from the window was uneven, so I drew the blind and switched on the lamps.
The album opened readily at the garden photograph. A crease in the sleeve caught the light and laid a white line across Simon’s face. I photographed the page as it was, then changed the angle and took another image to show the sleeve and the surrounding page. I wrote the date and the album’s position in the inventory in my notebook.
The caption sat beneath the photograph, its letters small and level.
Through the camera, the space between its two sentences was easy to see.
At the house I had read the sentence as a single claim. Here, looking through the camera, I could see the space after the full stop. The second sentence had not been squeezed in; the lettering occupied the strip comfortably. That did not tell me when it had been written. Someone could have prepared the entire strip with those words in mind.
I removed the sleeve from the album page and laid it flat. It opened along one side. The mount slid out without resistance when I supported it from beneath.
Nadia came over again. “Do you want another pair of hands?”
“Not yet. I’ll call you if I do.”
The mount was cream, its corners softened from handling. I photographed the front and reverse, then details of the edges. On the back, Dad had written August 2003 in pencil. There were no other marks I could confidently make out in the ordinary light. I turned it face up again.
Beth stood at the edge of the image. Her face was small enough that I had to move closer, but I did not need magnification to recognize her. Simon had said she hated the cardigan. I could almost hear a child complaining about its sleeves, though I could not remember whether I had heard Beth say it or had simply accepted his account.
I put the copy Lena had sent beside the mount, keeping each on its own clean sheet. The image was the same. Beneath it, the copy named Beth among the people at lunch. It also showed more of the surrounding mount than my calendar scan, but the copy’s tones flattened its surface. I could not make out the edges of the caption strip clearly enough to compare them.
I photographed the visible caption strip from directly above, then moved the lamp to one side. A shallow shadow followed part of its lower edge, widening slightly toward the raised right-hand corner.
I leaned closer.
The lifted corner cast a darker line than the rest. A narrow pale edge showed beneath it, irregular and difficult to separate visually from the surface below. I did not know whether I was looking at another piece of paper or the edge of a damaged mounting layer.
“Nadia?”
She set down her brush and came over. I moved aside so she could look without reaching across the photograph.
“Here,” I said, pointing beside the mount.
She bent close. “Can I change the light?”
I moved the lamp at her direction. The raised corner became more distinct. She looked for a while, then straightened.
“There may be paper underneath,” she said. “It could be a remnant from an earlier layer. I can’t tell how far it extends.”
I brought the magnifier over and adjusted it until the edge came into focus. The outer strip was slightly rough where it had lifted. Beneath it, the pale line disappeared under the caption. At its outermost point a little grey mark crossed the cream surface. It might have been dirt caught at the edge, or exposed adhesive, or something else entirely.
“There’s disturbance around it,” I said.
“Yes.”
“The rest of the mount has that even discolouration. This looks different.”
Nadia took my place at the magnifier. “It does. But I wouldn’t put a date on it.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
She looked up. “You were thinking one.”
I was. The rest of the mount had acquired the soft, settled appearance of an object left undisturbed for years. At the raised corner, a small patch looked cleaner. I could imagine a fingernail getting beneath the paper, lifting it, then pressing it down again. The image arrived so readily that I had to stop myself from describing it.
“Could it have happened when I took it out of the sleeve?” I asked.
“It could already have been like that. Did you get a clear photograph before you moved it?”
We checked the first images on the camera screen. In the view taken through the sleeve, reflections obscured the corner. Another showed a slight shadow at the edge, but I could not be certain it was the same one. The detail photograph, taken after I had removed the mount, showed it clearly.
I wrote that down: Right end of caption strip raised. Visible in detail photograph after removal from sleeve; earlier image inconclusive.
Nadia read the line as I finished it.
“That’s fair.”
“I supported the mount the whole way out.”
“I know. You can record that too.”
I did. The note looked defensive, so I added that the sleeve had opened along one side and that the mount had slid out without apparent resistance. The sequence mattered more than how carefully I believed I had behaved.
Nadia pulled a stool over. “What are you trying to prove?”
“That Dad changed the caption.”
The answer came quickly enough to make her look at me.
“Lena says he did,” I added. “There are two different wordings, and this is the one he kept in his album.”
“Those are useful things to know.” She glanced at the strip. “There may be an earlier layer here. That doesn’t tell us who put it there, or whether the two wordings you’ve seen account for all of it.”
“I didn’t say it did.”
“No. I asked what you were trying to prove.”
I set down my pencil. At the house I had wanted Simon to admit he knew when Dad had made the correction. At my bench I had wanted the object to contradict him. Those were not quite the same thing.
“Lena asked to meet me about it,” I said. “Now she’s missing, and Simon keeps asking for her copy. I want to understand why.”
Nadia rested her hands on her knees. “That makes sense. We can describe what’s here. We should leave the corner alone.”
I had not touched it, but I had considered how little movement it might take to see more. I put the magnifier back over the edge and took several photographs with the light at different angles. Under magnification, the pale layer remained only a sliver. I could not read anything beneath the visible caption, or tell whether any writing was there.
The raised paper looked vulnerable. It also looked as though someone had already made a choice about it.
“I’m going to put it away,” I said.
Nadia helped me prepare a protective enclosure. I recorded each step, including the album sleeve and the separate enclosure for the mount. I did not throw away the sleeve; it was part of the object’s recent housing, and Dad might have put it there himself. Once the mount was supported inside its enclosure, I closed the cover and wrote the contents and date on the outside.
My pencil paused over the word caption. I had written it twice in my notes already. The first time, my hand had made the letters compact enough to fit in the margin; the second time, I had left room.
Nadia carried her stool back to her bench.
“I can stay late if you need me,” she said.
“You’ve got your own work.”
“I know what I’ve got.”
“I’ll be all right. Thank you.”
She accepted that, though she left the studio door open when she went to make tea. The ordinary sounds of the building came through it: a tap running in the room next door, someone on the stairs, the latch of the downstairs door.
My phone began to ring.
The caller identified herself as a police officer and checked that I was somewhere I could speak. I stepped into the doorway, keeping the phone away from the worktable.
There was no news of Lena’s location, she said. The report remained open. She asked whether I had heard from her since making it.
“No. I sent her another message today.”
“What did you say?”
“That I’d found a photograph at our father’s house and was taking it to my studio. I asked her to call Tom.”
The officer asked about the photograph. I told her about Lena’s note and read her the two captions. The mount said Beth had arrived later; the family account said she arrived after the photograph, although Beth was visible in it.
“Does it show the accident?”
“No. It was taken at the lunch. The workshop isn’t in the picture.”
I could hear keys tapping. I waited until they stopped.
“There’s something else,” I said. “My uncle Simon asked for Lena’s copy last night. Before I told him she’d sent one, he asked whether she had sent me the photograph.”
“Did he explain how he knew?”
“He said Lena had been talking about photographs. Today he told me she’d shown him a copy on her phone a few days ago. I don’t know how he knew she might send one to me.”
I gave her his account as carefully as I could: Lena had come to see him, had been upset, and had become angry when he said she was mistaken about Daniel. Simon had said she was making trouble for Beth, but had not said Beth had told him that. He had also said he did not know where Lena was.
“Do you know if that was the argument she mentioned to Tom?” the officer asked.
“No. I wondered about it, but she didn’t name anyone to him.”
“And has Mr Mercer threatened Lena, as far as you know?”
“Not that I know of.”
I heard how little that answer gave her. I told her Simon had asked twice for the copy; I had refused, and he had not tried to take it.
She said she would add the information to the report and asked me to make contact if Lena called or if I remembered anything else relevant. I gave her Simon’s number, then checked that she had mine.
When the call ended, I stood in the doorway with the phone against my palm. Nadia had returned with two mugs. She set one on the small table outside the work area.
“Anything?” she asked.
“They haven’t found her.”
I told her what I had reported about Simon. She listened without offering an explanation for him, which was kinder than I felt at the time.
Back at my bench, I opened the photographs on the computer. The side light made the raised corner look larger than it had under the magnifier. I switched between the detail and the earlier image taken through the sleeve, trying to locate the same dark line beneath the reflection.
It might have been there.
I closed the earlier image and opened my notes. Disturbance appears different from surrounding surface. I added: Timing and cause unknown.
Someone could have handled that corner recently. It could have been Lena, Simon, Dad before he died, or me while removing the mount. The photographs did not settle it. I saved the note and left the enclosure closed.