Chapter 9: The Pilot on Paper
The envelope on Ama’s desk had READ THIS BEFORE HE DOES written across it in black marker.
“Was that meant for me?” I asked.
“No.” She turned the envelope over. “You weren’t supposed to be here until ten.”
“It’s ten-oh-two.”
“Then I’m behind.”
The Ward 7 office was quiet after the holiday. Someone had left a tin of shortbread beside the printer, and the last biscuit had broken into pieces too small to take without admitting how much I wanted it.
Ama slid the envelope into a drawer.
“I was going to ask you about it,” she said. “I wanted to read it first.”
“Comforting.”
“It should be. You once signed a birthday card that said ‘with deepest sympathy.’”
“It was underneath another card.”
“And you didn’t read it.”
“I read the name.”
She opened the drawer again and passed me three folded sheets. “These were delivered this morning. No return address.”
The first page was headed Residential Snow Service Comparison: Proposed Pilot. Halfway down, the name NorthPeak appeared beside two ward numbers.
“Seven and nine,” I said.
“Keep reading.”
The document described a limited trial using outside equipment for residential clearing. There were proposed reporting requirements, a spending ceiling and a note about city crews providing emergency coverage. Across the top of each page, in pale grey letters, was the word DRAFT.
I read the last page twice. “When does it start?”
“That version suggests mid-January.”
“Does Daphne know?”
“I don’t know. Does anyone know whether this is the version they’re using?”
I turned back to the first page. “Gord mentioned alternatives at council. He didn’t say they were this far along.”
“He may not have had this paper then.” Ama took the pages from me and tapped them straight. “Or he may have had a different one. We have a draft, Callum.”
I sat in the chair opposite her desk. The ceiling amount was large enough to make me sit forward, though I had no useful comparison for it. The document also referred to an existing administrative authorization.
“Can they do this without a vote?”
“According to that, a trial within the approved spending ceiling can be authorized administratively.” She pointed to the paragraph. “Permanent expansion would still need council approval. I’d like someone who knows the actual authorization to tell us whether this describes it accurately.”
“And what the trial measures.”
“Yes. Cost is on the page. Service quality gets three lines.”
I thought of the view from Ridgemont: beacons moving through streets I could see but couldn’t distinguish from one another. A cost per route would tell us something. It wouldn’t tell us whether a bus could get through or whether a driveway had been left with nowhere to put its snow.
“I should call Daphne.”
“You could. What would you ask her?”
“Whether she’s seen it.”
“And if she hasn’t?”
I looked at the draft. “I’d have given her an anonymous document and asked her to explain a decision she may not know about.”
Ama lifted her eyebrows. “You’re getting faster.”
“Please don’t mark my paper.”
“I’ve already found the red pen.”
She went back to her computer. I stood by the window while she searched the city’s public meeting material and purchasing notices. The street below had been cleared after the long system, though the corners were still high with snow. A man tried to step around a pile with a coffee tray and surrendered one cup to the sidewalk.
“No public decision here yet,” Ama said. “That doesn’t mean there won’t be one. We can ask.”
I pulled my notebook from my coat. On the page after Ridgemont, I wrote authorization, final scope, measures, emergency coverage. Then I added who monitors it?
“Ask for the contract too,” Ama said.
“Can we get it?”
“Ask what’s public. They may provide a summary before every detail is available.”
We drafted the request together. I wanted to include a sentence about my concern for the crews. Ama let me type it, then swivelled the screen towards herself.
“What answer does that sentence need?” she asked.
“It doesn’t need an answer.”
“Then save it for a conversation.”
I deleted it. The final request asked for the public decision when made, the authority and spending ceiling, the contract summary, the proposed wards, monitoring arrangements and provisions for emergency city coverage. It also asked what would require council approval.
Ama read it once. “That gives them something to answer.”
I sent it before I could add a paragraph about transparency.
The draft remained on her desk. “Should we tell anyone we have this?” I asked.
“We can say we’ve asked about a possible pilot. We shouldn’t present these terms as final.”
I touched the corner of the paper. “Someone wanted me to react.”
“Probably.”
“Do you think it was someone at the yard?”
“I think we have an envelope and no return address.”
I put the pages back inside. “You’d have been a very frustrating teacher.”
“I’d have made an excellent teacher. You’re the frustrating pupil.”
My phone buzzed. A message from Daphne, answering the New Year greeting I’d sent her after our trip to Ridgemont.
Happy New Year to you too. Harjit says I’m still allowed to wish people that until the seventh.
I smiled before I could stop myself.
Ama watched me. “News from the yard?”
“Harjit has set a deadline for greetings.”
“Good. We need more policy.”
I typed back: Please thank him for his service. Then I put the phone away and reached for a piece of broken shortbread.
On January 4, I called a man named Russell, who had responded to our office invitation. He answered on the fourth ring.
“Councillor. Did you find out when they’re clearing every driveway?”
“Not yet. I’m calling to understand what happens at yours.”
“What happens is I shovel it, the grader comes, and I shovel it again.”
I heard a television in the background, then the sound went down.
“How long does the second clearing take?” I asked.
“Depends. Twenty minutes, maybe. My neighbour takes longer.”
“Have you talked with her about what she needs?”
“She’s got a son who comes over. That’s not the point. We all pay taxes.”
He was right that they did. I also remembered Daphne’s questions about parked cars and places to put the snow.
“Would you support starting with people who have the hardest time clearing it?” I asked.
“Who decides that?”
“That’s one of the questions.”
“Then here’s another. If I’m healthy enough to do it, am I paying for my neighbour and still doing my own?”
“I think a limited service could be a first step, but I can’t promise a universal one without knowing what it would cost.”
Russell was quiet for a moment. “You promised it during the campaign.”
“I did.”
“I voted for you.”
“I understand why you’re frustrated.”
“I’d be more impressed if you understood how to fix it.”
After the call, I wrote his objection down without putting an answer beside it. I had answers I could offer about budgets and equipment, but he had asked a fair question, and I didn’t have the figures.
The next caller, Marlene, lived on a street where her daughter usually helped after a snowfall. Her daughter had recently injured her wrist.
“I don’t want a big sign on the house,” she said. “People can see well enough that I’m getting older.”
“I wasn’t thinking of signs.”
“Somebody will. They’ll need to tell the driver where to stop.”
I looked at the notebook. “Would you want help if there were a way to arrange it privately?”
“Possibly. I’d want someone to ask me first. And I don’t want to explain my medical history to everyone on the block.”
“You shouldn’t have to.”
“Can you promise that?”
“I can’t promise a system that hasn’t been designed. I can make sure privacy is one of the things we ask about.”
“All right,” she said. “Write that down.”
“I am.”
“And spell my name correctly if you use it.”
“I won’t use it without asking you.”
“Good. There’s an e on the end.”
I checked. There was.
Ilse was on her porch when I came home, trying to shake a runner free of snow. She stopped when she saw me.
“Don’t offer to do this,” she said. “I’ve nearly won.”
“I was going to offer to hold the door.”
“That would be useful.”
I held it while she gave the runner one final snap. A little snow landed on my boots.
“Victory,” she said, and laid it inside.
I stayed on the porch while she fetched her tea. The rail was cold through my glove. Across the street, a child in a green snowsuit was trying to climb a pile twice her height, with an adult stationed at the bottom.
Ilse returned with a mug for herself and one for me. “You look like you’ve been discussing municipal finance.”
“Worse. I’ve been discussing my campaign promises.”
She leaned against the doorframe. I meant to leave the callers’ names out, but Russell’s slipped out when I described his driveway, and Marlene’s followed when I mentioned her wish for privacy.
“Would you want neighbours checking on you after a storm?” I asked.
“Some of them already do.”
“Would you want me to organize something?”
“Not just yet.” She blew across her tea. “First ask the people who’d be doing the checking. They have their own driveways.”
“And the people being checked on.”
“Yes. I’d rather get a call I agreed to than find a stranger at my door telling me what I need.”
I thought of the names and numbers people had given the office. “Anyone we contact has chosen to hear from us. But agreeing to speak to me isn’t the same as agreeing to be on a list for neighbours.”
“Exactly.”
The child across the street slid down the snow pile on her stomach. Her accompanying adult applauded. She bowed, fell over and got up to do it again.
I took out my notebook and wrote permission for each use. Underneath it: who can see the list? how does someone leave it? what happens when help is full?
Ilse peered at the page. “You’ve got more questions.”
“I was hoping for a few answers today.”
“You got some. Russell wants his driveway cleared, and Marlene doesn’t want a sign.”
I looked up.
“You said their names just now,” she said. “I wasn’t eavesdropping. You were talking to me.”
“Right.” I closed the notebook. “I’ll leave their names out next time.”
Ilse took a sip of tea. “You’re allowed to learn, Callum. It’s one of your more useful habits.”
I watched the child start another climb. “I’m going to need a bigger notebook.”
“Try using both sides of the paper first.”