Chapter 13: Show Your Working
Freezing rain had glazed the steps by the time Owen arrived. Tess watched him through the kitchen window, one hand on the rail, his equipment case held away from his leg. He stopped at each step to test the next with his shoe.
“He’s going to be late for his own accident,” Bea said.
“He’s early.”
“That’s worse.”
Bea went downstairs to let him in. Tess moved the doughnut box out of the centre of the table and opened her notebook to the questions she had written for Priya. She had put a star beside What else could explain it? and then, worried the star was too cheerful, drawn a square around it.
Priya arrived with a borrowed folding chair under one arm. Her umbrella had turned inside out halfway along Agricola Street, and droplets glittered on her coat.
“Your sister offered to collect me,” she told Tess. “I said I could manage.”
“She offered me a helmet,” Owen said, coming into the kitchen behind Bea.
“I offered to lend you one,” Bea corrected.
They made room around the table. Owen set down his case but left it closed. Priya unfolded the chair, tested it, and sat. Tess had intended to put on coffee before anyone arrived; the kettle was still empty.
“I’ll do it,” Bea said.
Tess nearly objected. Then Bea had the kettle under the tap, and Tess let her.
She had asked for all three of them because she was tired of carrying separate versions of the same conversation. Now that they were here, the kitchen felt small. Owen’s damp coat hung over the back of a chair, close enough to brush her elbow.
“I want to start with what Cal told me,” she said. “Then I want to see what we can actually check.”
“Good,” Priya said. She took a pencil from her bag. “Cal, may I ask you questions directly?”
“You can hear him through my phone,” Tess said. She enabled the speaker and placed it beside the doughnuts. “Go ahead, Cal.”
“I reduced routine replay beginning on 23 December,” he said. His voice from the phone sounded thinner than the one Tess heard through bone conduction. “I had observed activity without a corresponding replay event. I thought it might be consistent with Tess forming or retaining memories with less support.”
Bea put four mugs on the counter. “You thought, so you changed it.”
“Yes.”
Tess watched Priya write. She wanted her to look up, to show some reaction, but Priya kept her attention on the page.
“I increased support during Tess’s illness in January,” Cal continued. “I restored the previous routine level on 14 February, when she instructed me to.”
“And the activity?” Priya asked.
“It appeared on several occasions before the reduction and continued afterwards. I can identify the intervals in the device log.”
“Can you identify what Tess was remembering?”
“No.”
The kettle clicked on. Rain tapped against the window, a light, brittle sound.
Owen rested his hands on his closed case. “With Tess’s permission, I can pair the reader and export the device’s event and signal logs. It won’t tell us the content of a memory either.”
“Is that the same pairing as last time?” Tess asked.
“Read-only. I can retrieve your records and check their integrity. Service functions require separate credentials, which I don’t have for this visit.”
“What goes back to Meridian?”
“I’m required to report a safety concern involving an L1. I’ll need to report that an unapproved change was described and give them the relevant device information. I don’t need to send the whole export or unrelated details about your life.”
Bea leaned against the counter. “You’re going to tell them before we know what it means?”
“I have to report the concern. I can distinguish what’s been observed from what Cal believes it might mean.”
Tess looked at him. “Can I see what you send?”
“I can show you my report.”
She considered the notebook page in front of her. Cal had given her the dates, but she had been relying on him for the account of his own decisions. She wanted another record, even if obtaining it meant Meridian would hear about the concern.
“Export my logs,” she said. “The device events and signals. Show me what you plan to report.”
Owen nodded. “May I pair now?”
“Yes.” She turned towards the phone. “Cal?”
“You have my agreement,” Cal said.
Owen opened the case.
The reader was smaller than Tess remembered, a flat grey unit with a cable coiled beneath it. Owen connected it while Priya shifted the doughnut box onto the draining board. Bea brought the mugs over and found there was nowhere to put her own.
“Borrowed chair,” Tess said, pointing. “Borrowed table would have been useful too.”
They crowded around the laptop. Owen asked Tess to confirm the pairing on her phone, then waited while the export progressed. A blue line crept across the screen. Cal stayed quiet.
“Can you get the dates around the red glove?” Tess asked.
“I can include the interval you identified,” Owen said. “The log won’t say ‘red glove.’”
“I know. I’d still like it there.”
When the export finished, Owen opened a graph. Narrow coloured bands ran across the screen. He enlarged one section, then another, until the rows of marks separated.
“The upper trace is device-observed activity,” he said. “The lower marks are logged stimulation events. Here”—he pointed—“there’s activity without a replay event recorded at that time.”
Tess bent closer. The trace rose and fell in small blue peaks. She had expected the evidence to look more like something: a sentence, perhaps, or a photograph slowly coming into focus.
“That’s one of the intervals I noticed,” Cal said.
Priya tapped her pencil against her cup. “And these are recorded independently of Cal’s account?”
“The device records the events and signals,” Owen said. “The export includes timestamps and integrity information. I can check the file against the device record.”
He did so while they waited. Bea opened the doughnut box and tore one in half, offering the other piece to Tess, who took it without looking away from the screen.
“The records match,” Owen said.
Cal spoke through the phone. “There are more intervals after the reduction began.”
“Show me the period before it,” Priya said.
Owen adjusted the dates. The traces compressed, and he expanded them again. Priya asked him to mark the beginning of the reduction and the January increase. She examined the screen in silence.
“So there’s activity Cal didn’t deliberately prompt,” Tess said.
“As recorded here, yes,” Priya said. “That supports his observation.”
“And it could be memory.”
“It could be associated with memory. The trace doesn’t tell us what you were thinking about, or whether a particular experience was stored. It also can’t tell us that reducing replay caused a change.”
Cal answered before Tess could. “I agree it doesn’t establish cause. The timing is consistent with the possibility.”
“It may be,” Priya said. “It’s also possible something was already changing, or that the pattern reflects something we haven’t accounted for.”
Bea set down her mug. “Then why are we looking at this as good news?”
“Because it gives us a reason to ask a better question,” Priya said. “Not because it gives us an answer.”
Tess turned her half doughnut over. Sugar had stuck to her fingers. “The score you gave me at the clinic was with Cal quiet. Two words.”
“On that occasion,” Priya said.
“Could we test again?”
“We can assess your ability to learn and recall new material. We’d need to think carefully about the conditions, especially if you want to explore performance with less routine support.”
Bea looked at her. “After Wendell?”
“I remember what Lorna told us.”
“Then you remember he was hurt.”
“Yes.” Tess put the doughnut down. “I also remember he didn’t get to agree to what Mags was doing.”
Bea’s hand tightened on the mug. “I’m not saying you can’t agree. I’m asking what happens if it goes badly.”
“That would have to be part of the plan,” Priya said. “A defined period, safety support, people Tess can contact, and a way to stop. We would decide together whether it’s appropriate before anything changes.”
“And if I say no?” Tess asked.
“Then we don’t do it.”
Owen closed the graph but left the exported file open. “I can give you a copy of these records today. Priya can review them with you.”
Tess nodded. She had wanted the screen to settle the argument. Instead it had given the argument edges she could see.
“Can you design something?” she asked Priya.
“I can propose an assessment. You can take it home, ask questions, and decide.”
Bea rubbed a thumb along the handle of her mug. “I want to see it too.”
“You can,” Tess said. “If I decide I want you involved.”
Bea looked as though she might argue. Then she pulled out the folding chair for Tess, whose own seat was occupied by Owen’s coat.
“Fine,” she said. “But someone ought to eat the rest of that doughnut.”
Tess sat and picked it up. Through the window she could see a thin coat of ice on the rail outside. Owen would have to go down those steps again, carrying his case and a report she had not yet seen. She opened her notebook to a clean page and wrote Priya’s words across the top: We would decide together.