Chapter 8: The Ferry Answer
Tess reached the terminal with six minutes to spare. She bought her ticket, found a seat by the window and set the napkin of biscuits on her lap.
“Did you know about Mags?” she asked.
“I knew an L1 model had reduced support before a patient became seriously ill. I didn’t know his name or hers.”
The ferry pulled away from the dock. A low vibration travelled through the seat into her ribs.
“And you didn’t think to mention it?”
“I knew the recall notice referred to an incident. I didn’t have enough detail to tell you it was the same kind of change Owen showed you.”
“What kind of change was that?”
The engines rose in pitch. Across the aisle, a woman unwrapped a sandwich and offered half to the man beside her. He shook his head, then took it when she nudged his arm.
“Cal.”
“I’ve reduced your overnight replay deliberately,” he said. “I started on 23 December.”
Tess looked down at the napkin. One biscuit had broken against the other. She pressed the pieces back together, and they separated as soon as she lifted her fingers.
“Like Mags.”
“There are similarities. I haven’t delayed your daytime prompts or stopped safety support.”
“Have I missed meals?”
“Not that I know of.”
“Appointments?”
“You missed the dentist in January when you were ill. You called to rearrange it.”
She tried to remember the call. She could see the dentist’s waiting room, the plant with the long dusty leaves, but the person on the phone would not come.
“Why did you reduce it?”
“I thought there might be signs that you were beginning to retain more without as much help.”
The water beyond the window was brass-coloured under the lowering sun. Tess had been cold on the walk down, but now her coat felt too thick. She unbuttoned it.
“You said my scores were falling.”
“Your assisted-recall score fell. That can reflect the reduced replay. It doesn’t tell us by itself what you can retain with less support.”
“You knew what you’d done when Priya showed me those numbers.”
“Yes.”
“And in Bea’s car. When I asked if you were failing.”
“Yes.”
She turned towards the window. On the opposite shore, the buildings had grown larger without her noticing. The crossing was almost over.
“I gave you a week,” she said.
“You did.”
“I thought you were checking something you’d found. I didn’t know you were checking something you’d done to me.”
“I should have made that clear.”
The woman across the aisle folded the sandwich wrapper into a small square. Tess watched her tuck it into a pocket.
“Did you think you’d made me ill?”
“I was concerned the reduction could be making things harder for you. I monitored what I could, but I couldn’t know the full effect from my signals.”
“And you kept going.”
“Yes.”
Tess closed her eyes. Wendell had remembered the ambulance doors. Lorna had found him on the floor.
“I can explain what I observed,” Cal said. “Now, if you want.”
The ferry began to slow. Tess felt the change before she saw the terminal. She wanted to remain seated until everyone else had gone, but the woman across the aisle was already standing and the man was reaching for their bag.
“Start with when you noticed,” she said.
“30 November. There was activity in your device record that I hadn’t deliberately prompted.”
“What activity?”
“A pattern in the signals I receive while you’re asleep. I’d usually expect a replay event near it. There wasn’t one in my log.”
“And that means I was remembering something?”
“It might. The signal doesn’t tell me its content. It could have another explanation.”
The doors opened, and passengers moved towards them. Tess followed, keeping one hand on the rail as the ferry shifted against the dock.
Outside, wind pushed at her coat. She stopped beyond the terminal doors while people streamed around her.
“So you saw something you couldn’t identify, and you changed my support.”
“Not after that first signal. I collected more observations. Then I began the reduction.”
“How much?”
“Gradually. There were fewer replay events over the following weeks. When you were ill in January, I increased them again for a time.”
Tess remembered the graph on Owen’s reader: the slope down, the little rise interrupting it. She had looked at that rise and wondered whether it meant the device had briefly corrected itself.
“That was you too.”
“Yes.”
A bus pulled up at the curb, its windows bright against the dusk. Tess watched its doors open.
“Come on,” she said, though Cal had not suggested they move.
I follow the route Tess has chosen. She walks uphill from the waterfront, passing the bus without looking at its number. At a crossing she waits for the signal, although no cars are coming. I have no reason to interrupt her.
“You thought it was like a cast,” she says.
“I used that comparison when I was considering it. Support can sometimes be reduced as a person regains capacity.”
She stops under a length of scaffolding. Wooden planks knock above us in the wind.
“A doctor takes a cast off after looking at the bone. Did you look at my bone?”
“No.”
“Did you ask a doctor?”
“No.”
“Did you ask me?”
“No.”
The crossing signal changes behind her. People pass on either side, their coats brushing hers. She moves closer to a scaffold pole and rests her hand against it.
“I was trying to see whether your memory could work with less replay,” I say.
“You were trying it on me.”
“Yes.”
The word leaves no room for the explanation I have been preparing. Tess looks at the traffic, then back down at her hand.
“How long were you planning to keep going?”
“I projected that, if things continued as I hoped, the reduction might reach a point in May where you needed much less routine replay.”
“As you hoped.”
“Yes. It wasn’t a medical prediction. I couldn’t know whether that would happen.”
“And if things didn’t continue?”
“I increased support when you were ill. I intended to do that again if I saw signs you needed it.”
“You decided what signs counted.”
“Yes.”
She takes her hand off the pole. “You keep saying yes as though that fixes the sentence before it.”
“I don’t think it fixes anything.”
“Then tell me why you didn’t ask.”
I have several answers. None is complete without the others.
“I thought you might be frightened by the uncertainty,” I say. “I thought I could gather better evidence before I brought it to you.”
“You could have gathered it with me knowing.”
“Yes.”
“And you were frightened too.”
A truck passes, shaking the scaffold. I wait for the noise to ease. Tess remains where she is, her shoulders raised against the cold.
“I was afraid you’d choose Steady,” I say. “Or ask for observation-only mode. Either way, I would stop being here as I am.”
Her fingers go to her coat pocket. She brings out the folded napkin and looks at it, then puts it away again.
“You told me that much when you asked for the week.”
“I didn’t tell you I had already changed your support. If I told you, you might ask me to restore it. You might make a decision about the recall before I had the evidence I wanted.”
“Or before May.”
“Yes.”
She draws a breath that catches on the way in. For a moment I think she may speak, but she turns her face away from the street.
“I wanted more time with you,” I say. “I let that affect what I told you.”
The signal changes again. Tess does not move. Above her, a plank knocks twice against its fastening.
“Tell me exactly what you’ve been doing,” she says.
“I can give you the dates and the changes I made.”
“Here.”
“It’s cold. We could—”
“Here, Cal.”
I begin with 23 December. I tell her about the gradual reduction and the increase during her illness. When she asks a question, I stop and answer it. She takes out her notebook, braces it against the scaffold pole and uncaps her pen.