Chapter 5: What Everyone Saw
By the time Marnie and I left the commons, the sun had dropped behind the church and the river path was in shade.
We had packed the stall in silence, Ivy working beside me until her mother came to collect her. She had folded the banner so carefully that its corners met. I had wanted to tell her she could leave it for me, but she seemed relieved to have something definite to do.
Marnie carried the cash tin under one arm. I had offered to take it, but she said I was already carrying two boxes and my handbag, and that she would hate to watch me drop everything into the river.
“You could have brought the wheelbarrow Tom promised,” she said.
“He promised it in case we sold the tables.”
“Did we?”
“No.”
“Then he’s off the hook.”
We walked a little farther. The river ran brown beneath the willows, with a few petals turning slowly in the water near the bank.
“I keep seeing Dawn at the chair,” I said. “Looking through his jacket.”
Marnie adjusted her grip on the tin. “She found the case quickly.”
“It didn’t feel quick.”
“No. I suppose it wouldn’t.”
A pair of boys came towards us on bicycles. We stepped onto the grass to let them pass, and one called an apology as his wheel scattered grit over my shoe. At another time Marnie might have called after him that he had missed her entirely and should have another try. She watched them go without speaking.
“I didn’t know Gil had an allergy,” I said.
“Neither did I.”
“He kept bees for years.”
“People can develop allergies later.”
I looked at her. “How do you know?”
“My cousin used to eat prawns by the bucket. Then one Christmas she couldn’t. She was furious, partly because she liked them and partly because her husband got the rest.”
“I thought you were going to say she’d been stung.”
“No. I don’t think she’d care for bees by the bucket.”
I smiled, briefly. “Dawn knew where to look.”
“She knew he wanted his jacket.”
“And the case was in the pocket.”
Marnie nodded, then stopped beside a bench. “Will you put those down a moment? The tin’s cutting into my arm.”
I set the boxes on the bench. She shifted the tin to her other side and rubbed her sleeve.
“I thought you reached him first,” she said.
“Me?”
“After Dawn went for the jacket.”
“You did. You put down your cake and went to him.”
“I moved the chair. I thought you were already there.”
“I came round the stall when I saw the case. I remember because Dawn left her bag on the table.”
Marnie frowned at the water. “Perhaps I only saw you after I’d moved the chair.”
“Perhaps I only saw you because you moved it.”
We stood with that for a moment. I could remember the plate in her hand, the pale icing, the chair legs catching on the grass. Yet when I tried to put them in order, people moved across one another, and Marjorie appeared through a gap I could no longer place.
“Marjorie was beside him before I got there,” Marnie said.
“Dawn was there too.”
“Yes, but I mean—” She stopped. “I don’t know what I mean. There were people between us.”
“Tom was at the other end of the display. And the volunteer with the phone.”
“And Ivy.”
“I sent her to keep the route clear.”
“She did. A man tried to come back in for his umbrella, and she told him he’d have to wait.”
“Heavens. Did he?”
“He took one look at her and went to stand in the rain.”
“It wasn’t raining.”
“That’s how persuasive she was.”
Marnie picked up the tin again. I lifted the boxes, and we resumed our walk. At the bend we could see the backs of the shops across the water, their upper windows catching the last light.
“Will they want to talk to everyone?” I asked.
“I don’t know. Someone spoke to Dawn, and Douglas was giving the ambulance crew names. They may ask the rest of us what we saw.”
I thought of the questions I could not answer. “Gil said he’d been stung. Then he wanted his jacket. I saw Dawn take out the case, but after that—”
“After that there were people trying to help.”
“I couldn’t see what was in it.”
“Neither could I.”
A dog trotted down the path towards us with a stick too long to fit comfortably between the hedge and the bench. Its owner followed, apologising to the dog for the difficulty. Marnie held the tin out of reach while the animal manoeuvred past.
“Do you suppose Dawn’s got someone with her?” I asked.
“Marjorie went home with her. I heard her tell Douglas.”
I was glad of that. I had last seen Dawn accepting her bag from me, her fingers closing around its handles without seeming to notice the weight. I hoped she had taken the honey out before putting it down.
At the footbridge Marnie stopped again, this time to look back across the commons. The marquee roof was visible above the hedge.
“Harriet was beside herself about that prize,” she said. “I saw her leaving with Douglas. She wouldn’t let him carry her cake boxes.”
“She’d spent weeks preparing.”
“I know. I’m not saying she shouldn’t have been upset.” Marnie shifted the tin. “I’m wondering whether she’ll feel bad about it now.”
“Gil was alive when she was upset with him.”
“Yes.” Marnie looked at me. “You’re allowed to be angry with someone and sorry they’ve died.”
I had not realised how much I wanted her to say it.
At the shops, she unlocked the connecting door from her side and carried the tin through to my counter. I found a pencil and a scrap of paper beneath the till.
“What are you doing?” she asked.
“Writing down what I want to ask. Before I decide I remember more than I do.”
I wrote: Who was where? Who called? Then, after a pause: Did anyone see inside the case?
Marnie read over my shoulder. “The volunteer called. Unless someone else did as well.”
“Then I’ll ask.”
She touched the edge of the paper. “Ask people how they are, too.”
“I will.”
She kissed my cheek. At the door she turned back. “I’m sorry I wasn’t more help with Ivy.”
“You helped pack the stall.”
“I meant before that.”
“She had me. And she had the umbrella man to deal with.”
Marnie managed a smile and went through to her own shop. I locked the connecting door after her, then checked the front and rear doors before going upstairs.
I woke while the windows were still dark. For a while I lay listening to a bird making one uncertain sound in the yard, then starting again. When sleep did not return, I put on my dressing gown and went down to the shop.
The air was cool. I switched on the lamp behind the counter and filled the kettle, keeping the tap low so the pipes would not knock. My list lay where I had left it. I turned it face down.
Peg’s most recent ledger sat on the shelf below the till. Its cover had warped slightly at one corner from a spill neither of us had ever admitted causing. I took it out and opened it on the counter while the water heated.
The early pages held honey yields, supplies and the dates Peg had paid for repairs. She had written ask for a proper receipt beside one entry and underlined it twice. A few pages later, the same instruction appeared beside a different name. Apparently the first recipient had disappointed her.
I ran a finger down a column of figures. Her sevens had a sharp little cross through them. Mine did not, though she had tried to teach me.
At the back, among notes about labels and a delivery of jars, she had written: Gil asking after the old boundary map again. Church copies?
I read it twice. There was no date beside the note, only the date at the top of the page, from the previous summer. Gil might have wanted the map for any number of reasons. I knew he was considering an offer on land near the orchard; I did not know whether a map had anything to do with it.
The kettle clicked off.
I made tea and brought the mug back to the counter. Farther down the page, separated from the map note by a list of jar sizes, was another line.
Gil knows something about Nell Plum. Ask Marjorie when she’s ready.
Nell had been Marjorie’s younger sister. I remembered her funeral, and the way grown-ups had lowered their voices when I came into a room. At fourteen, I had resented it fiercely. I could no longer have said what I had wanted to ask.
I looked at the sentence again. Peg had not written what Gil knew, or whether Marjorie had ever been ready to talk. She might have asked her already. She might have been wrong.
Outside, the bird found a more confident note. I took up the pencil and turned over my list.
Beneath the questions about the fair, I added two more: Where is the boundary map? What did Peg mean about Nell?
I closed the ledger, leaving my finger between the pages, and sat with my tea until the shop window began to lighten.