Chapter 20 of 35

AI-generated book by Adrian KnoxBook rights and permissions

Chapter 17: The Exception

The lift was quiet enough for Sabeen to hear the water moving in its shaft.

She sat on the chair beside her front door, working her foot into a shoe. The brace caught on the tongue. She tugged twice, then used the long wooden spoon she kept for the purpose.

Noor had come the previous evening with a reference number and an account of her lunch. Sabeen had listened until she reached the override, then sent her home.

“You’ve made the choice already,” she had said.

“I made it so you could decide.”

“You made it while I was at the clinic.”

Noor had not argued. That had irritated her too.

Now Sabeen had an appointment at the access point, and the folded queue notice was in her coat pocket. She had written the reference number on its back.

On the sixth-floor landing, the boy with the bicycle opened his aunt’s door.

“I heard you,” he said. “Trolley?”

“No trolley today.”

He looked at the stairs below her. “Want company?”

“You’ll have to walk slowly.”

“I can do that.”

He could not, quite. He kept reaching the next landing ahead of her and finding something to inspect until she caught up.

At the bottom, Sabeen thanked him and crossed the courtyard. The fan knocked in its housing. Someone had taped a new notice over the lift sign: PARTS ORDERED. There was no date.

The access point occupied the corner of a pharmacy. A woman behind a plastic screen took Sabeen’s reference and brought up her account.

“The interim restoration has been applied,” she said.

“Applied to what?”

“Your standing basis.”

“I know what the words are. Can you tell me what they mean for my position?”

The woman tapped twice. “Your next position notice is due with the monthly pass.”

“And before then?”

“I can request an updated estimate. It may not match the final position.”

“Request it, please.”

The woman did. While they waited, Sabeen watched a man at the next terminal trying to keep a small child from pressing the screen. The child succeeded twice. Each time he started the form again without raising his voice.

The estimate appeared.

“Eleven hundred and eighty-seven,” the woman said. “As of this morning.”

Sabeen held out her hand for the printout. The number was lower than 1,606. It was not 1,140.

“If I withdraw the override?”

“Your standing would be recalculated on the current basis. I can’t tell you the resulting position in advance.”

“Would I lose my place entirely?”

“No, you’d remain an applicant. Your position could change.”

Sabeen folded the printout once. “Who else can ask for one of these restorations?”

“Anyone can request a review of their assessment.”

“I asked who can get an override.”

The woman’s expression changed, a small withdrawal. “I don’t have the criteria for director-level overrides. I can give you the general appeals form.”

Sabeen took it. The form asked for the decision being appealed and provided six lines for the reason. She turned it over. The back was blank.

She bought milk at the pharmacy counter, then called Noor from the bench outside.

“I’ve seen the estimate,” she said when Noor answered. “Eleven eighty-seven.”

“That’s better.”

“Yes.” Sabeen shifted the milk onto her other side. “The woman couldn’t tell me what would happen if I withdrew it.”

“I can ask Pell’s team.”

“You can. I’m keeping it while you ask.”

The silence on the line was long enough for Sabeen to hear a bus braking.

“Are you all right with that?” Noor said.

“No. My hand still doesn’t work, though, and being fair won’t make the stairs shorter.”

“I didn’t mean—”

“I know what you meant.” Sabeen looked at the appeals form across her knees. “Tell me exactly what Ostrander wrote as the reason.”

Noor read it from the message she had copied: household assessment under review; interim restoration pending examination.

“And her name?”

“Genevieve Ostrander. She signed it.”

Sabeen wrote both on the blank back of the form, beneath the reference number. Her handwriting sloped where her fingers tired.

“Why are you writing it down?” Noor asked.

“So I can tell someone when they ask.”

“You don’t have to make it public.”

“I haven’t decided to.” Sabeen pressed the paper against her knee and added the date. “I’m deciding to remember who opened the door.”

At home, she placed the form beneath the sugar bowl with the two queue notices. The milk went into the fridge. She left her coat on while she rang the lift repair number and waited for somebody to answer.


Cass caught the woman outside the school gates as she was fastening a waterproof sleeve over her courier bag. Rain had made dark spots on the pavement but had not yet settled into a downpour.

“Ms Vale?”

She stopped with one hand on the clasp. “If this is about the kitchen, I’ve already told them I can’t cover Thursdays.”

“It isn’t. I’m Delia Mott’s son.”

Recognition came slowly. “Cass. Your mum used to save the burnt corners for me.”

“She said you were the only person who’d eat them.”

“She was right.”

Cass held up a folded slip of paper. “Dov Ferreira said you might talk to me about your notice. Only if you want to.”

Vale’s hand stayed on the bag. “What does he want with it?”

“He’s keeping copies of notices people bring in. I’m asking whether the reason on yours matched what you knew. We’re trying to find out which ones we can check.”

She glanced toward the school entrance. Children were coming through in pairs, loud beneath the awning.

“I gave him a copy,” she said. “It doesn’t mean I want my name anywhere.”

“You don’t have to.”

“Even if it helps?”

“Even then.”

She looked at him for another moment. “The notice said my address had been interrupted. It had. My building was cleared after the fire, and I was registered at my sister’s for six weeks.”

Cass lowered the slip. “Dov thought you might have documents.”

“I do. The temporary registration and the return date.”

“Would you let us see them?”

“What would that tell you?”

He had expected her to say the notice was wrong. He looked down at his mother’s old school gate, at the strip of yellow paint Delia had complained was always slippery.

“Because I don’t know what the interruption did to your application,” he said. “It could be a real thing without being the whole reason.”

Vale pulled the sleeve tight around her bag. “And if you can’t find out?”

“Then we say we can’t find out.”

She considered that. “I’ll show Dov the dates. You can write them down. No copies going anywhere else unless you ask me first.”

Cass folded the slip.

“I haven’t said I’ll stand up in a room.”

“I won’t ask you to.”

She gave him a brief nod and went through the gate.

Cass stayed under the awning while the rain strengthened. He had another name on his list, a man who repaired refrigeration units near the station. When Cass found him, the man listened to the first sentence, saw the paper in his hand and shook his head.

“My appeal’s still open.”

“We wouldn’t use your name without—”

“No.”

Cass put the slip away. “All right.”

The man’s shoulders eased. He went back inside, and Cass heard the rattle of a shutter coming down.

At Dov’s shop, Yaz was coaxing a printer roller out with a pair of tweezers. The machine lay open on the bench like a fish, its casing stacked neatly beside it.

“Did he throw you out?” Yaz asked.

“He said no before I got through the door.”

“Efficient.”

Dov emerged from the back carrying a mug. “And Vale?”

“She had the interruption. Six weeks after a fire. She’ll show you her registration dates, but nothing leaves here without asking her.”

Dov reached for a pencil. “I’d marked that one as a possible contradiction.”

“It isn’t.”

“It might be, if the dates—”

“The interruption happened.” Cass heard the edge in his voice and made himself slow down. “We don’t know what weight it had. She wants us to start there.”

Dov crossed out a line in his notebook. He did not tear the page out.

“And the others?” he asked.

“Two didn’t answer. One doesn’t want to be involved. Mrs Sen will bring her tenancy record tomorrow, and she said you can keep a copy here. Here, Dov. She hasn’t agreed to anything else.”

“I’ll write that beside it.”

Yaz extracted the roller and held it up. A thin black thread had wound itself around the spindle.

“That was the whole trouble,” they said.

Cass watched Dov mark the permissions in the notebook. Beside Vale’s name he wrote dates only; ask before sharing. Beside Sen’s he wrote copy held at shop.

“And Mum,” Cass said. “The same as before. Anonymous copy.”

Dov looked up. “Yes.”

Cass took Delia’s original receipt from his inside pocket. The cormorant watermark showed when he held it toward the window. Its address statement was still wrong, whatever the other notices turned out to say.

He put it away before the rain could reach it.