Chapter 1: The Empty Hall
At two in the morning, the seats in the Meridian Hall were cold enough to be felt through Helen’s coat.
Tobias stood in the centre aisle with a balloon in one hand and a pin in the other. He had taken off his gloves to tie the knot and now kept flexing his fingers.
“Where would you like me?”
“On the stage, please. About where the cellos sit.”
He went up the side steps, the balloon bright blue against his black coat. In the work lights the auditorium looked smaller than it did for a concert, its upper tiers drawn close around the empty floor. Helen had once known the number of seats in each section. She could still see where the calculations had failed to make allowance for the width of a particular armrest, and where an extra row had been squeezed in after the architect insisted it would fit.
Tobias held the balloon away from his face.
“Ready?”
“Wait.”
Helen moved three seats along and sat again. The upholstery gave a faint dry sigh. From here she could see the curved panels of the stage shell, their pale surfaces interrupted by the seams she had argued to retain. At the opening, someone had called them decorative. She had been too pleased with the rest of the evening to correct him.
“Go on.”
The crack made her shoulders rise. For an instant the sound seemed to fill the building; then it ran upward and away. Helen listened through the diminishing shiver, past the little noises Tobias made lowering his arm.
He waited.
“Again,” she said.
He found another balloon in his pocket and blew it up. She watched his cheeks redden, the knot resist his fingers. The second report was less sharp, but she heard the same quick thinning after it. There had been something else once: not louder, exactly, but a low persistence that seemed to arrive after she had stopped expecting it.
She could not say what year she had last heard it.
Tobias came down from the stage. “There’s a tail.”
Helen listened to the last of it fade.
“You don’t look convinced.”
“I’m not sure what I’m convinced of yet.”
He sat beside her and put the pin carefully through the neck of the unused balloon. “We could record one.”
“We could. But we’ve got the equipment set up for the sweeps.”
He glanced at her. “You wanted the balloons.”
“I did.” She picked a scrap of blue rubber from the next seat. “I wanted to listen before I started looking at a screen.”
Nadia Corr’s letter was folded in Helen’s bag. The cellist had written on behalf of the orchestra, though the impatience in it seemed personal. Players at the back of the platform were struggling to hear across the strings; passages that had once carried now felt exposed. Some had noticed it for several seasons, others only recently. The orchestra wanted the Trust to investigate before committing money to the anniversary programme.
At the bottom Nadia had added, in smaller handwriting: Please don’t tell us the hall is the same because the seats haven’t moved.
Helen had read that sentence twice. There were people who thought an acoustician’s job was to explain why a musician was mistaken. There were acousticians who had encouraged them.
Tobias stretched his legs into the aisle. “Have you met her?”
“Years ago. She played here when the hall opened.”
“She’s still here?”
“Apparently.”
“You make it sound unlikely.”
Helen looked at the stage. “I’m still here.”
He smiled, then seemed uncertain whether she had intended him to. He was twenty-seven, a graduate acoustician with a habit of asking the question directly after making an elaborate effort not to. He had been at Ardith & Pryce for eight months. When Dominic sent him to assist her, Helen had expected to spend much of the night explaining where to stand. Instead Tobias had arrived with the source positions marked on a copy of the old plan and a list of questions about the commissioning report.
“The orchestra could be right,” he said. “Even if we don’t find anything tonight.”
“Of course.”
“I didn’t mean—”
“I know what you meant.” She stood, pressing her palm against the seat for balance. “Let’s see what we can find.”
The loudspeaker stood on a tripod near the front of the stage, facing the seats. Tobias checked the cable where it crossed the floor and returned to the laptop on a folding table. A microphone had been set at the first receiver position, its small head raised to the height of a seated listener.
Helen had chosen positions that appeared to correspond to the 1994 commissioning notes. The notes were not as complete as she would now have required: a plan, a set of coordinates, a description of the source, and the results. They would need to return to the original record before claiming a close comparison.
Tobias read from his screen. “Empty hall, curtains as found, no audience. Temperature eighteen point one, relative humidity forty-four per cent. Ventilation off for the measurement.”
“Doors?”
“Closed. Ivo checked the backstage ones.”
Ivo Brandt, the technical director, had let them in shortly after midnight. He had shown Tobias the isolation switch for the ventilation, told them which lights would remain on, and gone back to his office with a flask and a newspaper. Helen had known him since the building was new. He had looked at her for a moment when she arrived, as though waiting to see whether she remembered him, and then taken her coat without asking.
Tobias fitted the calibrator over the microphone. The reference tone sounded, thin and steady.
“Level’s good,” he said.
Helen wrote it down in her notebook, though he was logging it too. She liked having something she could consult without waking a computer. Tobias had once offered to photograph her notes after a site visit; she had agreed, then spent the journey home wondering if he had thought her incapable of doing it herself.
The first sweep rose from a low, almost bodily vibration to a hard, high whistle. Helen had heard thousands of them. In the Meridian it was still unpleasant enough to make her clench her jaw.
When it stopped, Tobias bent over the screen.
“Well?”
“I’d rather check the run before I tell you.”
“Good answer.”
He replayed the result through the analysis, then brought up the band figures. Helen stood behind him, close enough to see the numbers but not the expression on his face.
“That’s lower,” he said.
The old mid-frequency average in the report was 2.62 seconds. His preliminary calculation gave 2.28. At 500 hertz, the difference from the reported commissioning value was nearer two-tenths of a second.
“Check the microphone position,” she said.
He looked up. “It’s on the mark.”
“Check it anyway.”
He got up without replying. Helen took the tape measure from the table and held its end against the seat-frame datum while he extended it to the tripod. The position was within the tolerance they had agreed.
Tobias let the tape run back into its case. “I could move it a little forward.”
“Leave it where it is. Run the calibration again, then we’ll repeat.”
The reference tone held. They ran another sweep and got a similar result. At the next receiver position, farther back and to one side, the figure shifted but remained below the old average. Tobias checked the files were being saved under separate names. Helen watched him do it, then made herself look away.
Onstage, the loudspeaker’s cable made a black line across the boards. She remembered the first concert she had attended here after the opening, arriving late and standing at the back until an usher found her a seat. She had been occupied for weeks with another project and had almost forgotten the pleasure of hearing the room full of people. Even before the music began, the hall had seemed alert to them: the sound of a programme dropped, a cough answered from somewhere above.
That memory was not a measurement either. The audience, the stage, even the equipment had been different.
“We’ll need the source specifications from the old tests,” she said. “And the environmental readings, if they kept them.”
Tobias nodded. “And a proper comparison of positions.”
“The old report may not give us enough for that.”
“Does that mean we can’t say there’s a change?”
“It means we say what we’ve found, and how sure we are.” She pointed to the screen. “Repeatable tonight, at these positions, under these conditions. The comparison suggests a loss. We’ll need to establish how close the old conditions were.”
He typed while she spoke. She had meant the words for both of them.
A door opened at the side of the stalls. Ivo came in carrying his flask.
“Can I put the air back on?” he asked. “It’s like a butcher’s shop down here.”
“Another twenty minutes,” Tobias said.
Ivo looked toward Helen. “Anything interesting?”
“We’ve got a difference from the commissioning figures.”
“Bad difference?”
“We don’t know why it’s there yet.”
He unscrewed the flask lid. “The players will be glad somebody’s found something.”
He went back through the door before Helen could ask what he had heard from them.
Tobias saved the latest run and looked up. “One more position?”
“One more. Then we check the calibration at the end.”
He carried the microphone down the row, lifting its stand over the folded seats. Helen followed with the tape. On her way she stopped and turned towards the stage. In the working light the diffuser panels were ordinary pieces of construction, jointed and painted, each one where the drawings had put it.
She had come expecting to reassure the orchestra, or at least to tell them what kind of reassurance was possible. Now she would have to ask for the old records, and time to read them.
Tobias held the end of the tape against the floor.
“Here?”
Helen checked the plan. “A little to your left.”
He moved the stand. She crouched to read the measurement, called it out, and watched him make the adjustment.
“Ready when you are,” he said.
She returned to the table and pressed the key. The rising sound passed through the empty seats again, and both of them waited for it to finish.