Chapter 13: The Bid
Dominic’s office looked across the river towards the converted mill where Helen lived. In the morning light she could see her own window, or one close to it, divided into small panes by the old iron frame.
He had cleared the table before she arrived. A pad lay square with its edge, a pen across the top. Helen put her folder opposite it.
“I thought you wanted the results of the tape analysis,” he said.
“I do. There’s more.”
She took out the 2011 letter first. Dominic read the date and turned to the signature. His mouth tightened, though he said nothing until he had reached the end.
“Is this your only copy?”
“It’s the one in my file. Ivo may have another with the project records.”
“And the drawings?”
“Returned to the client, according to the file. Tobias is looking for them in the archive. Ivo has been looking too.”
Dominic read the reassurance about the auditorium again. He rested his pen on the page without marking it.
“Do we know yet where the enclosure went?”
“Not precisely. Ivo believes it occupies part of a space behind the shell. He saw the boarded arrangement during fit-out, but he wasn’t there when the blockwork was left incomplete. He was told about that by colleagues.”
“And you’ve seen the space?”
“The access panel. We need permission and a safety assessment before it’s opened.”
Dominic looked up. “You didn’t go in?”
Helen shook her head.
Dominic returned his attention to the letter.
Helen took the sleeved sheet from the folder and slid it towards him. The pencil had faded enough that he leaned forward to read it.
“This is yours as well?”
“February 1994. The building wasn’t finished. I heard a late decay and wrote down a possible coupled volume.”
He studied the crossed-out words. “Who’s WR?”
“The contractor. I meant to ask them about it.”
“And then?”
“I crossed it out.”
Dominic waited. He had the habit of leaving a silence long enough for someone else to fill it. In meetings Helen had admired the economy of it.
“I didn’t know about the missing blockwork,” she said. “I didn’t know the size of the space. I thought there might be a coupled volume and chose not to ask.”
“Did you remember that when you wrote the 2011 letter?”
“I can’t say I did. I found the sheet in the drawing wallet last week. The letter doesn’t mention it, and I have no memory of looking at it then.”
He set the page down. “Have you told anyone about this?”
“Tobias knows I found the review. I sent it to him this morning. He hasn’t seen the 1994 sheet.”
“What about the Trust?”
“Not yet.”
“Why not?”
“I wanted to know what we were obliged to do, and I wanted you to hear it from me.” She touched the edge of the sleeve. “Those are different reasons.”
Dominic moved the letter and the sheet apart. “They are.”
He asked her to take him through the measurements. She described the difference between the commissioning figures and their recent readings, the uncertainty around conditions in 1994, and the bend in Duncan’s tape. Dominic stopped her twice to ask what a term meant. When she told him the tape was consistent with coupling, he wrote the phrase down.
“Could the array have produced that?”
“The array scatters sound. We measured that. It performs as designed in the relevant bands.” She drew the pad towards her and sketched a rough line. “But the published case study credits it with more of the hall’s overall behaviour than we can safely support now. The low-frequency decay is particularly difficult to explain that way.”
“What changed in 2011?”
“We don’t know enough yet. The enclosure may have altered the volume or its connection to the hall. Other things could have changed too. We need the drawings and a survey.”
She drew a line roughly six metres long on his copy of the plan. “If this section could come out, perhaps the space could be opened up. That assumes the services can be moved or protected; we haven’t seen what’s inside. It’s an option to investigate, not a recommendation.”
Dominic looked at the sketch. “I’ll show Beatrix what sort of question the survey has to answer.”
Dominic held out his hand for the pen. He marked the sketch as provisional and underlined may in his notes. Helen felt an irritation so sharp that she nearly asked him not to do it. Then he wrote other changes beside the line.
“The bid goes in next week,” he said.
Helen watched him underline the date.
“If we’re involved in a review of our own predecessor’s advice, that has to be made clear. And we can’t promise a restoration on this evidence.”
“We never should have promised one.”
“We haven’t submitted it.”
He got up and went to the window. Below them a delivery van was reversing towards the warehouse entrance, its warning signal faint through the glass. Dominic watched until it stopped.
“I’ll suspend the bid today,” he said. “I need to speak to our insurers before we make any statement about the 2011 advice. We’ll also need independent legal and professional advice. I can’t tell you what the consequences will be for the firm, or for you.”
Helen had expected resistance. The speed of his decision left her with nothing ready to say.
“There are people working on that bid,” she said.
“They’ll be disappointed.” He turned back. “They’ll be more disappointed if we win it and someone later asks why we didn’t disclose this.”
He returned to the table and checked the date on the letter once more. “I want copies of everything, including the raw data and the transfer notes. Keep the originals as they are. Don’t annotate the old documents.”
“I’ll leave them as they are.”
“I’m saying it to everyone who has them. We need a record of what was found, where, and when.”
Tobias had already made such a record for the tape. Helen thought of the entry he had made about her request to hear it first, and of how she had resented seeing it there.
“I’ll send you the file list,” she said.
“Thank you.” Dominic picked up the phone, then put it down again. “Is there anything else I should know before I call?”
Helen considered Duncan’s note, her draft attribution, the paper she had published eight years later. She told him about each. He listened without interrupting, adding a date or a name to his pad when she paused.
By the time she finished, the river had lost its morning brightness. Dominic turned the pad around so she could check his notes.
“You’ve written that Duncan told me to investigate,” she said.
“Is that wrong?”
“The note asks for the void to be investigated. I can’t reconstruct exactly what he said to me. I don’t want us making the account more certain in either direction.”
Dominic crossed out told Helen and wrote note requests investigation.
His call took place with the office door closed. Helen sat in the small meeting room next door, looking at a set of samples for an education project: pale acoustic panels arranged on a board, each labelled with its absorption figures. Through the wall she could hear Dominic’s voice rise and fall without making out the words.
When he came to fetch her, he had taken off his jacket.
“The insurer will want the documents. They’re arranging advice.” He glanced at his watch. “I’ve told the bid team to stop work. I haven’t given them the history.”
In his office, the coffee he had made her was cold. She drank some anyway.
“Until we’ve had advice, I’d be careful about describing the 2011 letter as the cause,” he said. “That isn’t established.”
“I said a possible contribution.”
“I know. You also said, on the phone yesterday, ‘I did this.’”
Helen put down the cup. “I was talking about the advice.”
“You may have been. The distinction won’t necessarily survive being repeated.”
He sat opposite her. “There’s a report the Trust needs now: what the orchestra has observed, what our measurements show, what we can and can’t infer from the tape. We can identify the riser works as something to investigate and recommend an independent survey. That gets them useful information quickly.”
“And the sheet?”
“We preserve it. We take advice on how the historical documents should be presented.”
“Presented to whom?”
“To the insurer, initially. Then we establish what the Trust needs and when.”
Helen looked at the two pages on his table. The 1994 sheet had slipped inside its sleeve; one corner was folded back against the plastic. She resisted the urge to straighten it.
“The Trust needs to know I suspected a volume,” she said.
“They need the building investigated. The sheet is relevant to that, but it doesn’t tell us where the volume is or what happened to it. You’d be giving them a personal account before we’ve even established the geometry.”
“It tells them I had a reason to ask and didn’t.”
His voice remained level. “The report I’m describing would be accurate as far as it went. It would help the hall. It would also give us time to understand the position of the people who worked on the later project. Some are still here.”
A gull passed the window, close enough for Helen to see the dark tips of its wings. It tilted above the water and disappeared below the sill.
“I want them protected too,” she said.
“So do I.”
“But I’d be protected by leaving it out.”
Dominic did not answer at once. He turned her empty cup by its handle, setting it squarely on the saucer.
“You would,” he said. “That doesn’t automatically make the narrower report wrong. It does mean we should be honest about why it appeals.”
She had imagined a confession delivered cleanly, with the documents placed in front of someone who could decide what they meant. Dominic had given her a more complicated task: to supply evidence without deciding its meaning herself. The narrower report offered relief from that, at least for a while. It also offered a way to continue sounding useful.
“I’m not deciding today,” she said.
“All right. But we can’t sit on the measurements indefinitely.”
“I won’t ask you to.”
“And Tobias?”
“He needs independent advice.” She thought of him at her table, checking the transfer notes before he would play the cassette. “He worked on this with me, and I asked him to restrict the tape at first. He should be able to speak to someone outside the project.”
Dominic nodded. “I’ll arrange for him to have that option. He can choose whom he speaks to.”
“Please don’t make it depend on whether he stays on the bid.”
“There is no bid at the moment.”
“You know what I mean.”
“He’ll have the choice.”
He gathered his notes but left the original documents where they were. Helen replaced the 1994 sheet in her folder, keeping it flat this time. The 2011 letter went beside it.
At the door she stopped. “The Trust will need copies. I’m not agreeing to withhold them.”
“I understand,” Dominic said. “Let’s get the advice, then speak again promptly.”
Helen went back to her office and opened the message she had sent Tobias that morning. The letter was attached. Beneath it he had replied: Received. I’ll add it to the project record.
She began another message, telling him about the sheet. She wrote three sentences, read them, and deleted the last two. The first remained on the screen while she considered whether he would be at his desk.
Then she typed: I’ve found another document from 1994. We need to talk about it. You should also know Dominic is arranging access to independent advice for you.
She sent it before she could revise the words again.